ATR
AptarGroup, Inc.stockNYSE
At CloseNov 13, 2026 3:59:58 PM EST
143.03USD+0.924%(+1.31)546,914
Pre-marketNov 13, 2026 9:17:30 AM EST
141.95USD+0.162%(+0.23)
After-hoursNov 13, 2026 4:10:30 PM EST
143.09USD+0.042%(+0.06)
ATR Reddit Mentions by subreddit
Loading…
ATR Mentions × sentiment
Loading…
ATR Specific Mentions latest comments & posts
Yes, I did plan to test for the worst days and am thinking about the appropriate measures. But it's not so easy to know if -1% premarket day will become -10%, or even end up as +5%.
I am thinking about adding flexible trailing stop loss, which would depend not just on ATR but on several other things, but it will probably be a long backtesting until I find something good. Even then, forward testing and paper testing might be crap. Even if those are good, live performance might be crap 😁
It's also possible that I did design everything perfectly, but market conditions and interdependencies changed too much, rendering my bot useless. But I look at this bot project more like an intellectual challenge, not really expecting much from it.
sentiment 0.881
Switching off the setups that need expansion, like the breakouts and the tight-band scalper, when ATR sits in a low percentile is usually simpler than shrinking targets on the fly, since moving targets adds another knob to overfit. Check that the filter also keeps the good stretch intact and doesn't just dodge the bad one. A drop over a few dozen trades can also be partly noise, so I'd want it to hold across more than one chop period.
sentiment 0.268
I'd keep the regime part separate from the strategies. One thing decides the regime (even something simple like ATR percentile plus trend slope, or an HMM if you want to go further), and each strategy only gets a size budget in the regimes where its own backtest held up. Stops them fighting each other on the same bar. What are you using as the regime signal right now?
sentiment -0.077
wall so it can't pollute the core book's conviction scores. We strip out GICS sector and 5 basic OHLCV style factors (size, mom, 5d reversal, ATR vol) on every live event, and if a shadow scout proves positive residual alpha out of sample it automatically earns canary weight, and then gets culled automatically when the feed gets crowded or decays. Zero LLMs anywhere in the stack, just Blom rank quantiles and shrunk IC weighting.
sentiment 0.595
Looking to share notes with anyone running a similar setup.
So we know that if a dataset has a clean 10-year point-in-time archive you can run a textbook walk-forward backtest on, the big multi-manager pods have already arbed 80% of the juice out of it. On the flip side, the weird ephemeral alt-data streams that actually have uncrowded alpha right now almost never have clean historical archives.
The way we ended up solving it was splitting our stack into two layers feeding one risk combiner:
First layer is the boring proven foundation - 100% deterministic scouts on primary filings (SEC XBRL, Form 4, 8-K, patents, FDA across 3,607 Russell 3000 CIKs with 555 delisted tickers left in). That part is fully walk-forward backtested (+61.8% unlevered from 2022-2026 vs SPY +54.3%) and keeps the lights on without needing leverage.
Second layer is basically a Darwinian sandbox for ephemeral alt-data scouts that can't be backtested 10 years back. Every new scout starts at $0 in shadow behind a one-way glass wall so it can't pollute the core book's conviction scores. We strip out GICS sector and 5 basic OHLCV style factors (size, mom, 5d reversal, ATR vol) on every live event, and if a shadow scout proves positive residual alpha out of sample it automatically earns canary weight, and then gets culled automatically when the feed gets crowded or decays. Zero LLMs anywhere in the stack, just Blom rank quantiles and shrunk IC weighting.
For anyone else running hybrid setups like this where you mix long-history signals with short-history/ephemeral feeds... how fast are you letting live shadow signals graduate to real capital vs killing them? If you wait 200+ events to promote a short-lived inefficiency, the edge is usually gone by the time you size it up, but promote too fast and you're just funding noise.
(If anyone wants to see the exact math we're using, we put our architecture notes and working papers up at https://starlingquant.com and https://starlingquant.com/guides)
sentiment 0.699
that'd be my first suspect too. 100 points at 10K is a 1% move, at 30K it's a third of that, so the old years were really trading a different rule. rescale the distances to % of price or a multiple of ATR and rerun 2016-2021. if it still loses there, the edge belongs to the recent regime, not the idea.
sentiment -0.542
A price-vs-200-day-SMA z-score isn’t the same as a return-volatility z-score, so the result depends a lot on how the deviation is defined and can stay extreme during a regime shift. I’d compare it with ATR/realized volatility and check how often similar readings led to a reversal versus further downside, rather than treating -4σ as a signal by itself. A reclaim of the average or a higher low would be more useful confirmation than the extreme reading alone.
sentiment -0.293
I think the ATR does a decent job for me. I always have a target to some pivot but trailing has been my best option.
sentiment 0.778
lots of stocks are sitting on the edges of their ATR might as well go long
sentiment 0.273
I recommend starting with futures MES, NES (S&P500) and/or MNQ, NNQ (Nasdaq) as you don't need a lot of capital to start out trading especially with the new nano futures NES/NNQ where you can swing trade with as little as $500 and to also keep the dollar amount small as you start out learning incase of mistakes. Also paper trading initially might be best just to get used to placing orders etc
Get a TradingView subscription that allows you to divide your screen into 4 separate chart windows and have the 2 minute, 15 minute, 1 hour and 1 day time frames up for the specific market you choose, I recommend MNQ/NNQ.
Put VWAP (Volume Weighted Average Price) on all 4 charts and make sure to enable Bands Multiplier #2 & Bands Multiplier #3 in the settings so you have all 3 deviations of VWAP visible for each chart. Also I recommend unchecking Bands Fill 1,2&3 to get rid of the colored shading that's on by default
For the 5 minute set the VWAP anchor period to session
For the 15 minute set the VWAP anchor period to week
For the 1 hour set the VWAP anchor period to month
For the 1 day set the VWAP anchor period to quarter
Learn to see how price reacts to VWAP and its 3 deviations across all 4 time frames and you'll start to notice a pattern in price action especially when deviation 3 is reached and even more so if price is at deviation 3 on more than one time frame. Also watch for when price has been holding above or below the VWAP midline across hours/days and then finally comes back to reach the VWAP midline, you'll usually see a sharp reaction back to the side it was previously held in, before another bounce or 2 potentially breaks price out to the other side.
Price likes to move in the direction where there is more room you'll start to see so shooting across the other side of VWAP instead of just moving from deviation 2 to 3 is usually a more appealing direction for price to go.
During the start of a new week/month/quarter, those VWAPs start out compressed so just use the session VWAP until those widen out.
VWAP gives much better context on where price is at and likely heading than just candles over blank space. The quarterly VWAP is the slowest and mainly just gives you the over all trend direction you're trading in.
Also recommend adding the basic volume indicator to the 5min chart
I also use bollinger bands across all 4 to watch for bollinger squeezes and as a visual overlay form of RSI but not necessary to begin with and might clutter your charts but they are also a great way to recognize patterns in price action than just candles alone.
Learning what ATR is and how to use it to measure volatility and correctly size your stop losses would be a good thing to have an understanding of but ultimately just having a wide enough stop out of reach is best as long as you're aiming for 2RR or more and keeping within risk limits of around 1-2%. Also using previous day/major lows/highs or VWAP deviations as defense walls for your stops to sit outside of is a good tactic.
The VIX is also another way to gauge volatility
The Nasdaq and the S&P 500 move very similar due to arbitrage so having another screen where you can watch both markets simultaneously can be helpful if one or the other is approaching an important level but not essential at the beginning.
Also watching the price of crude oil (CL), copper (HG), platinum (PL) and 10 year bond yields (US10Y) can be helpful incase one spikes but also not necessary to begin with but good to have an understanding on how these markets are connected as well as gold (GC) (XAUUSD) and the US dollar (DXY).
Use the website [https://www.forexfactory.com](https://www.forexfactory.com) to keep track of upcoming important news events colored red like FOMC CPI Jobs etc and be cautious or avoid trading right around these news events but take note on the outcome and the market reaction to them.
This is a free journal you can use to log your trades once you get the hang of things and use Win+Shift+S to capture screenshots to add to your journal entries [https://v2.stonkjournal.com](https://v2.stonkjournal.com)
Try a bit of back testing using the quad chart set up I mentioned to quick fire train your eyes to how price moves and reacts to VWAP and its deviations and you'll start to understand why price reverses or launches suddenly.
Don't waste tons of time learning useless information and strategies like I did in the beginning, train your eyes yourself to read price action + VWAP and you'll be starting out the right way
sentiment 0.992
