chartexchange

Letters to the Editor, October 19th: On protecting citizens from hardship, public service pay and buying second hand books from Britain

The Irish Times | Oct 19, 2026 1:00 AM EDT

Sir, – As a society when did we become so dependent on the State to save us from any hardship? The current severe inflation being experienced and projected is as a result of wars started and continued by big powers who do not care about the consequences. There is no state in the world that can insulate its citizens from these rising costs. We in Ireland are largely a wealthy country and very many can well afford to tighten their own belts and ride this out. Instead we have every sector and group banging their drums and putting their hands out. This makes it harder for the State to help those who really need it. – Yours, etc, CLAIRE O’MALLEY, Blackrock, Dublin. Public sector pay increases Sir, – One can only agree with Stephen Collins’ assertion that over generous pay increases for the public sector will eventually undermine our economy, (“ Unsustainable pay increases for public sector workers will put Ireland’s stability at risk ” Opinion and Analysis, October 16th). Having said that, it is blatantly wrong that many civil servants, teachers and nurses in permanent and pensionable jobs can no longer afford to buy a house. While it is correct to point out that overall numbers in the public sector have risen to dizzy heights, the real focus should be on particular areas of the public sector and individual Government departments that have boosted their staff allocations and pay to levels that merit serious scrutiny. The Government has never entered into discussions with the public sector unions on foot of the completion of a root and branch analysis in relation to pay and public service numbers. Such an exercise could legitimise and strengthen the Government’s position and also provide more scope and flexibility in relation to pay. In the context of the current impasse, there is a clear opportunity and need for such an approach. – Yours, etc, MARTIN MCDONALD, Terenure, Dublin 12. Sir, – Whenever the subject of public sector pay is in the news, we can always expect the public sector “bashers” to come out of the woodwork. However, I was still a bit dismayed by Stephen Collins’s article blaming the public sector workers for the financial crash of 2009. I was a public sector worker in 2009 and I still vividly recall the burning sense of injustice felt by myself and my colleagues at that time. Many despairingly asked their union reps “Why are we being blamed for this”, as we endured pay cut after pay cut (a fact omitted by Collins). The fact was that we were simply a popular and convenient scapegoat at the time. Of course, the true facts of what caused the financial crash subsequently emerged and are now in the public records. – Yours, etc, TOM FANTHOM, Newcastle, Co Wicklow. Understanding Donald Trump Sir, – I am a simple fellow with limited political intuition and as a consequence, find it difficult to understand why US president Donald Trump appears more sympathetic to Russia than to Ukraine, a country fighting for its survival against an aggressive dictatorship. He criticises Ukraine for striking Russian oil refineries, while at the same time restricting access to technology that could strengthen its war effort. Meanwhile, Trump wants to purchase Russian oil that will provide revenue to that regime, helping to fund and sustain its conflict against Ukraine. What am I missing? Amid this grave international situation, Trump finds time to bask in newly contrived awards and honours, apparently generated to compensate for the genuine accolades that have rightly eluded him. I cannot help wondering if the presidency has become a stage on which one man’s appetite for admiration must continually be satisfied, rather than being a force for good in a world that badly needs intelligent and compassionate leadership. – Yours, etc, GEOFF SCARGILL, Bray, Co Wicklow. Sir, – Somebody needs to sit down with Donald Trump to explain to him why we are experiencing oil and diesel shortages, resulting in higher prices. As a consequence of his attack on Iran, the Strait of Hormuz and the Red Sea are closed to shipping bringing oil and diesel and many other products to the rest of the world. We are all experiencing rising prices and inflation, but I believe we all know who is responsible. Ukraine is currently targeting Russian oil refineries. This is in retaliation for Russia indiscriminate and unprovoked attacks on people and resources in Ukraine. Trump’s defence of Russia is truly shocking and has all to do with self interest on his part, rather than on justice for the people of Ukraine. Please, please, can somebody explain this to Trump. Just be aware, he appears to be a slow learner. – Yours, etc, PAULA MOLLOY, Baldoyle, Dublin 13. Screen break Sir, – Two weeks back we accidentally broke the fibre optic cable providing Wifi and internet to the house. After the initial panic, pandemonium and search for alternative accommodation, things calmed down. My evenings were spent in the company of John Creedon’s music programme on RTÉ Radio 1 and with a good book – was reading, and enjoying, Leo Varadkar’s autobiography, Speaking My Mind. To my surprise I survived, and to my amazement I actually enjoyed the two screen free weeks which brought me back to times past. – Yours, etc, GARY DOYLE, Straffan, Co Kildare. Bridge builder Sir, – Recent correspondence to your page suggested that card playing has become less inspiring than video games. Let me assure you as a mature bridge player that there is nothing to compare with the pure pleasure of an evening spent in the company of a hall full of vigorous card players. Firstly the game is alive, it’s challenging, it’s almost always friendly, importantly it’s competitive and it gives one an excuse to get one’s hair done, to don a sparkly top and to compel one’s granddaughter to paint one’s nails. Is this not more life-giving than sitting in a dark room watching a video game called Grand Theft Auto? – Yours, etc. VAL FITZPATRICK, Raheny, Dublin 5. Changes in customs charges Sir, – The recent changes in import and customs charges may have been designed to offset the surge in cheap Chinese goods, but it appears to have had a more damaging and I would hope unintended consequence: the price of second hand books from the UK has now skyrocketed. This morning I attempted to buy a book online that was priced at £4.78, but when I specified I was in Ireland, the price changed £13.78. After some investigation, it seems this is common across reputable booksellers. Shipping, thankfully, was free. – Yours, etc, ANTHONY BEHAN, Killeagh, Co Cork. Every dog should be DNA-certified. Sir, – Irish sheep farmers know the distress and financial losses caused by dog attacks on livestock. A compulsory national dog DNA database would help identify dogs responsible and hold their owners accountable. But its benefits would extend far beyond protecting sheep. The current pre-legislative process for the Dog Breeding Establishments (Amendment) Bill 2026 provides a timely opportunity to demand this change. While farming organisations and several independent politicians have repeatedly called for a compulsory national dog DNA database, the present debate on the Dog Breeding Industry is too good an opportunity for sheep farmers to pass up. Without a DNA database the approximately 45,000 people who adopt, purchase or otherwise acquire a dog each year have no reliable way of knowing their new family member’s genetic coefficient of inbreeding. This is a material fact affecting inherited disease risks and animal welfare. There is no reason to justify consumers being denied access to this information before purchase or adoption. Over the past decade, Ireland’s commercial puppy-farming industry has reportedly produced around 100,000 puppies annually. Concerns about inbreeding and the effectiveness of oversight make independent, verifiable genetic information – coupled to microchip registration – increasingly important. Mandatory DNA profiling, linked to microchip identification and appropriate genetic testing, could help trace livestock attacks, exposé irresponsible breeding practices, improve animal welfare and give responsible breeders a means of demonstrating their standards. It could also give buyers greater confidence in the dogs they acquire. This measure alone would significantly reduce local authority inspection time and costs. Sheep farmers have a direct interest in this reform. They should urge their representative organisations and public representatives to seek mandatory DNA certification for every dog in Ireland while the 2026 Bill is under consideration. This is an opportunity to protect livestock, consumers, and children from dog bite injuries. – Yours, etc, CIARAN WALSH, Newbridge, Co Kildare. Origins of the Citroën 2CV Sir, – The Citroën 2CV being relaunched can only be good news, as probably only the VW Beetle holds a comparable place in automotive nostalgia. The origin of its name is an elegant encapsulation of the ingenuity of the original car, and its being “designed to reduce costs” as Emmet Ryan says (October 15th). The letters mean deux chevaux or two horses, a reference in a sense to the vehicle’s horsepower. At the time in France car tax was calculated on the basis of measurement of the chambers within the engine, and what they would be predicted to do. And those of the 2CV put it in the lowest category, and thus the cheapest for taxing it. Nonetheless the actual power was very much higher, reportedly in the region of 7-9 horsepower when launched. A miracle of modern engineering then, in the 1940s. Later models were far more powerful but the name was retained. As a comparison, on a quick search I think the lowest powered car on the Irish market now delivers 45 horsepower, with most being in the hundreds. But few, if any, have the 2CV’s panache. – Yours etc, BRIAN O’BRIEN, Kinsale, Co Cork. Memory triggers Sir, – The Irishman’s Diary (October 15th), about the very popular adventure stories of Reics Carlo, triggered memories from our 1950s Irish class. From our modest school library, we had to select an individual Reics Carlo book, read it and present a review/synopsis the following week. While some lads struggled, others, who were more proficient in the Gaeilge, made light work of the reviews. Soon, those elegant synopses, were circulating gratis among the weaker students, who then copied them in their own handwriting and handed them in. The Brother never twigged what happened. A trouble shared was a trouble halved. -– Yours etc. PATRICK JUDGE, Dún Laoghaire, Co Dublin.

Read original article