Transcript: Ann Berry, Threadneedle Founder & CIO on Providing Capital to Tech Companies:
The transcript from this week’s MiB: Ann Berry, Threadneedle Founder & CIO on Providing Capital to Tech Cos. , is below.
You can stream and download our full conversation, including any podcast extras, on Apple Podcasts , Spotify , YouTube , and Bloomberg . All of our earlier podcasts on your favorite pod hosts can be found here .
~~~
MASTERS IN BUSINESS Ann Berry, Founder and Managing Partner, Threadneedle
Hosted by Barry Ritholtz • Bloomberg Radio
Transcript
[00:00:02] Bloomberg Audio Studios. Podcasts. Radio. News.
[00:00:07] BARRY RITHOLTZ: This week on the podcast, what can I say? Another banger. Ann Berry has a fascinating background in everything from startups to private equity to M&A and LBOs. She was at Goldman.
She’s worked at a number of really fascinating places. Her firm, Threadneedle, specializes in early-stage technology, industrial, and investment platform investments. She’s worked both in New York and London and around the world—such a unique perspective on the world of startup investing as well as mature company investing. I found this conversation to be absolutely fascinating, and I think you will also. With no further ado, my sit-down with Threadneedle’s Ann Berry. Ann Berry, welcome to Bloomberg.
[00:01:06] ANN BERRY: Thanks for welcoming me in, Barry. Great to see you.
[00:01:09] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Great to see you. So I want to talk about your career and the state of the world today, but before we do, I have to dive into your background. Double first in economics at Trinity College, which is in Cambridge. What is a double first? What does that mean?
[00:01:27] ANN BERRY: It means I was a complete geek, super nerd, and studied all the time when I was at Cambridge University. It’s the equivalent here of summa cum laude. But then within that, a small double-first subset.
[00:01:37] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Got it. Exactly. Then you go from economics at Cambridge to Harvard Biz School. Was the original career plan always finance and investing?
[00:01:46] ANN BERRY: You know, it wasn’t. If you had asked me as a kid, I would’ve said I was going to be Indiana Jones and I was going to be an archaeologist. And then I sort of had the astronaut phase, which we all do.
[00:01:55] BARRY RITHOLTZ: No paleontologist phase?
[00:01:57] ANN BERRY: Looking for a dinosaur? No. It’s a great question. No, I didn’t actually go there. I did want to be a journalist, which I can come back to, because it really demonstrates a passion for storytelling. But I’m very honest about why I went into finance. I came from a family—we had absolutely no money whatsoever. I grew up with government-assisted housing as my home, and I was the first in my family to go to college. And so I really felt the importance of finding financial stability. And growing up in London, I looked around and thought, where could I find that in a career? And financial services seemed to me the clearest, nearest path to try and get there.
[00:02:35] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So interesting. I never had the astronaut career path, but the fighter pilot career path was always out there and intriguing.
[00:02:43] ANN BERRY: Really? Was that a lot of Top Gun? A little Top—
[00:02:45] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Gun, not so much Top Gun as the World War II planes. By the time we get to the modern era, it’s push a button and the missiles take care of—
[00:02:54] ANN BERRY: Everything. So you like the Spitfires?
[00:02:56] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Oh, for sure. Absolutely. Mustangs, Spitfires, a hundred percent. So your first gig out of school—did you start at Goldman Sachs?
[00:03:03] ANN BERRY: I did. I started in mergers and acquisitions at Goldman in London.
[00:03:07] BARRY RITHOLTZ: All right. How long were you in London, and when did you come to New York?
[00:03:09] ANN BERRY: So I spent my first two years in London at Goldman in mergers and acquisitions. And then I moved over, still in London, still within Goldman, to private equity. And that’s when my career in investing started, doing European leverage—
[00:03:22] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Buyouts. So that’s an interesting transition, going from advising on transactions to actually being responsible for the investment itself. How much of the LBO and M&A translated to PE? We’ll have fun with acronyms today. And how much of it was like, oh, this is a whole different world?
[00:03:41] ANN BERRY: Well, you know, mergers and acquisitions provided unbelievable training, and I was very lucky, ’cause I was at Goldman Sachs in a period of time that was still very much the old-school apprenticeship model. Senior people really focused on making sure that very junior, entry-level people were learning. And so meticulous attention to detail became core to what I was doing every day. Independent thinking became core to what I was doing.
But I decided pretty quickly I did not want to be, you know, advising only. I really wanted to be closer to the action when it came to decision-making. And I’ll come back to that, ’cause I wanted to get even closer to becoming the decision-maker ultimately. But that was my transition from the advisory side to the private equity investing side. And there was a lot of technical overlap in some of the basic skills, but the mindset was very different. And the level of curiosity I found I needed to have to be in private equity was a step up from where I was previously.
[00:04:36] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Did you end up at Cornell Capital next? Or was there something in between?
[00:04:39] ANN BERRY: No. After my three years at Goldman in London, I crossed the Atlantic. I came to America, and I’d always wanted to be in New York, but a mentor of mine at Goldman said, “Before you decide to go and try to conquer the Big Apple, why don’t you consider going to business school?” And at the time, Barry, Brits weren’t really going to business school en masse. And so when I said I’m going to do this and I’m going to go to America for business school, some folks I worked with—two fabulous women, I’ll always remember this, Theresa Teague and Kira Ick, whom I was working with at the time—both were graduates of Harvard Business School. And they said, “Go, go have a life experience, meet interesting global people, broaden your horizons, understand what other people your age have been doing by way of their professions. It’s not all finance out there. So go, and you can decide to go back to finance, but it doesn’t need to be now. And you can go to New York afterwards.” So I was lucky. I was lucky to have those voices and that encouragement, because it was an unbelievable experience for me.
[00:05:38] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So what was the first gig right out of HBS?
[00:05:41] ANN BERRY: Well, I have a great knack for graduating into recessions. So coming out of Harvard Business School, I graduated into the financial crisis. So I came to New York in 2008. I was very lucky to have a job. Goldman honored their offer to me, which had been extended to me in 2007.
[00:05:56] BARRY RITHOLTZ: They ended up doing pretty okay during the financial crisis. Some companies did a little better, a lot did a whole lot worse. But it was definitely a lot of stress. What was it like starting your career right in the middle of that storm?
[00:06:13] ANN BERRY: So to paint the picture, I joined Goldman at a time when every couple of weeks people would just disappear from the cubes around me. And I’m pretty sure I was kept ’cause I was just very cheap, right? ’Cause I was really entry level coming out of business school. And the stress levels were incredibly high. And I remember Lloyd Blankfein, who was CEO at the time—he was actually very good about sending out frequent voicemails. It was a big voicemail culture. And you’d see your phone bleeping, your desk phone bleeping, and his voicemails would start: “This is Lloyd with an update.” And those would come around pretty frequently. And I learned weekly—
[00:06:49] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Daily?
[00:06:49] ANN BERRY: Sometimes several times a week, particularly if the headlines were rolling, just to clarify what was going on. And I will say I was very impressed that, while I’m sure the senior folks were incredibly stressed, both personally and professionally, the people I worked with did a pretty good job of emanating at least a feeling of calm—that things will be all right. And no one was under any illusion that things were going to be easy.
And there was always a question around which of the banks would survive. I remember the moment that Goldman became a bank holding company. Lots of people who’d grown up at Goldman weren’t particularly excited about that. But there was a sense that Goldman would figure it out. So I was lucky to be there at that time. And I learned a lot, by the way, from my portfolio companies, the businesses, ’cause I was in private equity at Goldman in ’08—the things you have to do to help companies survive. And I’ll just plant one, ’cause it became very important later in my career, Barry: I inherited an oil field services company—
[00:07:48] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Meaning someone else at the firm was responsible?
[00:07:51] ANN BERRY: They had made the investment. And I joined the team, so I was supporting a senior person. And this business had struggled, as many did; it had a lot of leverage on it. But it had the wherewithal to pull down on its revolver to max out its cash balance, right, as they could see the problems were coming. And I was tasked with figuring out where to cut cost, how to reserve that cash. It was very operational. It was unusual for private equity. And it’s a lesson that I held onto when, fast forward to COVID, I was CEO of a business where all of my clients were hotels. So it’s a lesson that I learned and carried with me, and it turned out to be important.
[00:08:32] BARRY RITHOLTZ: People don’t realize, during these big crises, it’s a tremendous learning opportunity—
[00:08:36] ANN BERRY: Fabulous learning experience.
[00:08:37] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Amongst the wreckage and the tragedies, there’s a lot of opportunity for learning, for growth. It always reminds me of Robert Duvall in Apocalypse Now: “One day this war’s gonna end.” It’s like wistful longing for a unique opportunity. You have to just really be present for that.
All right, so post-Goldman, post-MBA, you go to Cornell Capital. Is that the next stop along the line?
[00:09:08] ANN BERRY: Right. So post–business school, I spent about nine-ish years at Goldman—I think it was nine years at Goldman—in New York, in the merchant bank, as it was then called, doing private equity investing. So leveraged buyouts, some structured credit, across a number of sectors. And I’d had a mentor at Goldman who was the vice chairman of this group. And he retired from Goldman Sachs and decided that he loved investing too much and wanted to get in there and have his own fun. So I left Goldman. I actually tried to think about what I wanted to do, and started to dip my toe into live television at that point in time, which we can come back to. But ultimately I joined Cornell Capital and became a partner, a deal partner there, member of the investment committee.
And I continued to do what I’d been doing before at Goldman, but now in a much more entrepreneurial environment. ’Cause when you’re out there hustling to find deals and to work with management teams, and you don’t come from a big brand like Goldman Sachs, it’s a really different crash course in business development, which was great for me. So to my personality—
[00:10:07] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So that was New York and Hong Kong, focusing on consumer, financials, and business. Curious, moving from a big organization like Goldman to a smaller firm, how do you source opportunities? How do you make decisions in a much smaller shop? You mentioned you have to hustle for deals. It can’t just be that simple. It has to be a very, very different experience.
[00:10:33] ANN BERRY: Well, you don’t have brand recognition. But what you do have, when you go from a big place like Goldman—where at that point I’d been there for nearly twelve years in the aggregate—and go to somewhere new, is a repository of relationships that you’ve tended over time, and you have your own reputation. So I didn’t have a completely standing start, right? There were management teams. I’d worked with boards, I’d served with CEOs, I knew other private equity firms. I’d done deals alongside or opposite them over time, and a lot of bankers who were the gateways to a lot of these LBO opportunities. And they were very good to me. I will tell you, Barry, when I left Goldman, I wondered who would take my calls, right? Who would call me back. And you figure out who those people are.
And I’ll give you one example. Pretty early in my time at Cornell, there was one investment I wanted to make, and it was to buy an industrial services business. And it was an auction process. And the lead banker selling the business I’d met briefly beforehand. And this business was owned by a number of families and a sponsor, but really the families had a vote. And I said, “Let’s get on a plane and go meet all of the families and the operators, and let me walk the floor and tell them my story. And if we like the business, we’ll get it done really quickly—like in four weeks—if you give me exclusivity.” And he did it, and he was as good as his word, and I was as good as my word. And that deal got done.
[00:12:01] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So that leads me to something: smaller firm, a little more nimble, faster decision-making, a whole lot—the ability to not take six months to do something that should take six days, six weeks.
[00:12:13] ANN BERRY: Yes. Now, it’s not true of every small firm, because a lot of it has got to do with—size itself doesn’t dictate pace. I’ve seen that in a number of different places. But I think the right people with the right mindset—and in this case these were very entrepreneurial folks at Cornell Capital—didn’t want to give up quality of work, but they were much happier to lean into speed. It was a much flatter organization.
[00:12:36] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So you hinted at past media experience. Somewhere along that run was NBCUniversal, doing digital media corporate development. What year was that? Was that pre-GFC or after?
[00:12:50] ANN BERRY: That was during my summer at business school. So that was my summer internship—back to relationships. I had a fabulous mentor at Goldman in London, Gordon Dial. He was a senior in the M&A group, and I’d worked with him in my first two years on a big deal. And when I applied to business school, he was gracious enough to write some of my recommendations and then gracious enough to put me in touch with GE, which you may remember owned NBC at the time. So I spent my summer there, and I look back now and sort of join the dots on the signs that media was going to play some sort of role in my life.
But actually, in terms of going on screen, I was on gardening leave after I left Goldman Sachs at the end of 2016, trying to figure out what to do next. And a dear friend of mine is Jessica Tarlov, who is the liberal host on The Five on Fox. She just wrote a new book. I disagree. At the time she was sort of making her way up through Fox, and she said, “Have you thought about media?” I said, “Well, funnily enough, the BBC has just put out a call to try and find more business experts. I think I might give it a shot”—and run down to the stock exchange and send a video. Jesse was very kind, and her father at the time helped me try to do a demo tape. And we sent it in, Barry, and I didn’t even get a response confirming that it had been received. And Jesse, being a very dear friend and loyal friend, I think was so personally affronted by this, since she was now invested in it, that she put me in touch with Fox, and I started doing Fox Business News at, you know, five o’clock in the morning. And then my TV appearances started, talking about the markets.
[00:14:20] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Not just Fox, but you eventually start doing Bloomberg—
[00:14:23] ANN BERRY: CNBC, Bloomberg—
[00:14:25] BARRY RITHOLTZ: CNN. The whole run. How did you end up at Jimmy Kimmel’s media platform, Wheelhouse?
[00:14:32] ANN BERRY: So after Cornell Capital—well, there’s a chapter within Cornell Capital which meant a lot to me. I became the CEO of one of the largest portfolio companies in their portfolio, called PureStar. And—
[00:14:44] BARRY RITHOLTZ: That was during the pandemic, right?
[00:14:45] ANN BERRY: It was during the pandemic. It was an investment that was made in 2018, and I became CEO in late 2019 and ended up running the business through—
[00:14:53] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Through—
[00:14:54] ANN BERRY: The pandemic, through the lockdown.
[00:14:55] BARRY RITHOLTZ: And this is the hospitality company where you’re working with hotels and—
[00:14:59] ANN BERRY: Re—
[00:14:59] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Restaurants, which are all suffering tremendously, right, when their guests can’t show up. Well, let me—
[00:15:05] ANN BERRY: Tell you a story for how it became clear things were going to get tough for that business, which by the way is doing incredibly well today. I always remember this. It was early 2020, and Vegas had just had CES, the Consumer Electronics Show—big deal. Vegas, an important market in hospitality. And I was out there, and I’ll always remember this, Barry: I was sitting in the office, and several generations of one family, who had grown up in this business starting at the age of seventeen, came to me, and they said, “Ann, something’s going on. Our clients are seeing mass cancellations.” I said, “What do you mean? Where are they coming from?” “They’re from Asia.” This is February 2020.
[00:15:47] BARRY RITHOLTZ: That’s late already.
[00:15:48] ANN BERRY: This is February 2020. But much earlier than when we had the lockdowns come and the shutdowns come. And I said, “When have you seen something like this?” And he said, “The last time we saw something like this was avian flu.” Fast forward, my antenna’s up. So I decided not to come back to New York. I stayed in Vegas to try and see what was going on. And then, fast forward, when it was clear that the country was going to have to go on some kind of shutdown, I went back to the same group and said, “We need to get ready. We need PPE, we need sanitation equipment.” And they said, “We’ve got this. We did this already, because we’ve seen this before. We’ve stocked up.”
And that was a lesson to me, Barry: listen to the people on the front lines, and make sure you have relationships with the workers doing the really hard work. Don’t just sit on Mount Olympus where all the C-suite are when you’re running a business. You need to get in there and you need to know your people, and they need to be comfortable coming to you with their ideas and observations.
[00:16:44] BARRY RITHOLTZ: You never know where that early insight is. And there’s a quote—you and I were chatting about quotes earlier. There’s a quote that everybody misunderstands, which is, “The plural of anecdote is not data.” That’s the quote everybody uses. But the guy who originally coined that was a professor—I want to say Caltech, I can’t swear by it—who taught statistics. And the original quote was, “The plural of anecdote isn’t data, but it should be the starting point for further research, because a series of anecdotes might end up totaling up to data.” So those guys have seen it before, they start to see anecdotal cancellations, and suddenly, hey, are these anecdotes, or are we seeing a data wave that’s going to lead us to an interesting conclusion?
So how did you end up taking over as CEO? The family just said, “Hey, you seem to know what you’re doing. Why don’t you come in and run this so we can go out and do our thing?”
[00:17:50] ANN BERRY: Well, it was sponsor-owned when the business was acquired, and when it came into our portfolio, it was just a case of a fantastic business in its core: outsourced laundry. So hotels—you need it. Like a utility, you send your sheets and towels out on a truck—
[00:18:06] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Linens, tablecloths—
[00:18:07] ANN BERRY: Restaurants, yes. Exactly. Sheets and towels, for the most part. So it’s really in the bedroom you need them, right? They’re so core to the experience. So a truck would come up every day, drop off the clean ones, take the dirty ones. It doesn’t sound the most glamorous business. But I gotta tell you, I fell in love with it. As a passionate traveler myself, I sort of understood the need and the importance it had. And it was a fabulous business. It just wasn’t leaning into growth and fulfilling its potential in the way that we on the investment committee knew that it could.
So I ended up sort of in the seat and quickly got to work, traveling around to most of the, at the time, thirty-ish locations, talking to people on the front line and doing something, Barry, which I believe is really important, and I’ll explain why: trying to identify talent that could do more, but that no one had given the opportunity yet. Which is something I’d been very blessed to experience in my career on Wall Street—on deals I’d worked on, mentors I’d worked with through Goldman, who gave me outsized opportunity to lead. And I wanted to find those people here to see if that was a way to unlock growth, to flatten the reporting lines. And in a way, it’s almost a tech startup kind of mentality, right? It’s how you really empower folks to come forward and give the best talent the chance to run, even if it’s unorthodox, in unorthodox—
[00:19:24] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Spots. So picking up and washing and delivering towels, sheets, linens, tablecloths—you said not sexy, but that’s a media construct. I’m looking at some of the investments you’ve made. You’ve got hair-color technology, Airship software for service contractors, Allure Beauty Concepts, Reality Defender. None of these are—well, maybe Reality Defender, deepfakes, that is a little sexy. But most of this is blocking and tackling. Why should it matter if something is sexy? We were talking about quantum before, and fintech. If it makes money and it’s ignored by the rest of the market, does it really matter?
[00:20:11] ANN BERRY: And the thing, you know, the irony here is I’m invested in the glamorous stuff too. I’m in a sports league. I’m in Unrivaled. I’m in some pretty glamorous AI businesses. I was lucky to invest behind Yann LeCun in his latest world models business, AMI. So I’m in those too. But what I find glamorous, what I find sexy, is great execution and really solving a problem in a way that doesn’t have to be the most off-the-charts or, you know, the most out-of-the-box, but is executed against with real intention and real discipline and rigor. And the businesses that I’ve invested in and run, or I’m on the boards of, are super focused on execution. And nothing gives me more joy, Barry, than rolling up my sleeves to participate in the execution and then putting my money where my mouth is—and my time is—with my capital.
[00:20:58] BARRY RITHOLTZ: You are on both sides of the trade. Sometimes you’re an advisor, sometimes you’re an investor, sometimes you’re actually part of the company doing management. How do each of those three roles reinforce and cross-pollinate each other?
[00:21:14] ANN BERRY: So I came to learn this. There’s a story I’ll share with you. I strongly believe that operating and being inside a company makes one a better financial investor. And I say this as someone who, for the first big chunk of my career, was traditional Wall Street, right? In the spreadsheets, doing the typical diligence. It’s all rather desktop until the day you are actually inside one of these businesses and actually doing the doing and being held accountable as part of the management team.
And I’ll tell you the story, Barry. I was in Vegas, and it was the depths of the pandemic. This was probably April or May. And there was a moment when it was clear thousands of the team would have to be furloughed to keep the company able to survive this and get through to the other end, which it did do. And I’d been very lucky, because while I’d been at Goldman, I’d been Goldman’s representative on the board of a number of the businesses I’d been investing in with the teams there. And I had good relationships with many of the CEOs, and one in particular, Mike Grebe, who had been the CEO of a company called Interline Brands, which ultimately we sold to Home Depot. And I stayed in touch with Mike Grebe, and I called him from the empty parking lot of a hundred-thousand-square-foot facility in Vegas—empty because, unfortunately, we’d had to do these difficult things to keep the business alive. And I said, “Mike, it’s Ann Berry.” He always takes my call. I said, “I’m retroactively apologizing to you and every other CEO whose board I sat on as a mid-level private equity person, piping up during board meetings with comments I thought were adding value based on insights from my spreadsheets. It must have been so annoying for you, because life actually doing it is different. It’s about the people, it’s about the rhythm of the business.” And he laughed, and he was very gracious and said nice things. And I called others, and they all appreciated it. Life is different.
Having been in the seat makes me a better board member, a much better investor. I know what to look for in diligence. It makes these conversations more fun. I could speak to you, Barry, because you operate your own business. And I think that experience is incredibly underrated.
[00:23:29] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Really super interesting. Coming up, we continue our conversation with Ann Berry, founder and managing partner of Threadneedle, talking about making the leap from private equity to operating an investment firm. I’m Barry Ritholtz, and you’re listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio.
I’m Barry Ritholtz. You’re listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio. Ann Berry, founder and managing partner of Threadneedle, is my extra-special guest this week. The firm provides capital and advice to high-growth private companies and investment platforms. So let’s delve a little bit into providing advice and capital. Why both? Why not just write a check?
[00:24:15] ANN BERRY: Because I think the most interesting problems, or the most interesting opportunities for change for companies at a point of inflection, Barry, come from having real operational value-add. There’s a lot of capital out there. You know, you’ve got a lot of capital, you’re a capital provider. There’s a lot out there. But combining that with operational help is what gets me really excited, and where I thought I could differentiate myself in this world of private investing.
[00:24:40] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So I’m really curious: is every startup different, or is every era a little different than the one before? Are there some patterns you begin to see? Are there some similarities across sectors, across eras, that allow you to pull out a gem of wisdom and share it? Or is it a case of first impression each and every time?
[00:25:04] ANN BERRY: Well, it’s interesting, ’cause you really called out the earlier-stage investing. I do early-stage investing, but one of the reasons I decided I wanted to have my own firm—having been at Goldman and Cornell, then at a place called Wheelhouse, which you called out, which was solely focused on early stage—I didn’t want to leave behind the world of mature businesses. I think that there’s a ton of opportunity with companies that have been around for a long time. They’re business services, outsourced businesses, industrial companies, which to me have just as much exciting growth opportunity as some of the early-stage businesses that I look at.
And the thing that is common to all of the ones I choose to get involved with, Barry, is that there is a leader, an executive team, that I have a high level of conviction will be able to execute, get the goals of the business achieved. And those goals may change over time, which is nice to talk about, but come hell or high water, they’re going to find a way to make this work, and they’re going to achieve an outcome that I would deem acceptable from a return perspective. So—
[00:26:11] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So you’ve invested across so many different stages. I want to have you define them for listeners—everything from friends and family to seed to an A round to an established company, private or public, that needs help integrating a new process or a new technology that’ll unlock a whole lot of value. Tell us about the different stages that you consider.
[00:26:38] ANN BERRY: So from the fund perspective, the earliest I would get to is a seed stage, meaning—
[00:26:41] BARRY RITHOLTZ: After friends and family?
[00:26:43] ANN BERRY: And they’re up and running. Yeah, I mean, I do those too. I do my own angel investing. I’m friends and family to some of those in whom I’ve invested, and some of those have worked out incredibly well. But in terms of where the real rigor and the discipline of pattern spotting and looking for the repeatable themes comes in, it’s that sort of Series A onwards, sometimes the seed, through to very mature companies. And the thread, as I just said, is always looking for businesses where I do believe that there is a cultural focus on execution. And quite frankly, the ones where I’ve become involved and taken on an operating role have been businesses with the potential to be great but that don’t yet have that focus on executional excellence. And where I’ve dropped in, it’s actually to bring that to the table in the blocking and tackling day to day.
Now, there are a couple of other things that I do look for. I do focus on cash, even for the early-stage businesses. A little unusually—a lot of venture capital folks, it’s all about top-line growth. The cash burn rate isn’t as much of a focus for them, even from the get-go. I’m focused on: can this business be cash-flowing fairly quickly, relative, again, to others?
[00:27:51] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Define “quickly.” Is that three months, a year?
[00:27:54] ANN BERRY: For the very early-stage businesses, I’d like to see free cash flow within about two years, which for that sort of early stage is pretty quick. As we know, there are public companies in tech spaces that have gone public—IPO’d—without having necessarily line of sight to free cash flow. But I can’t help myself; private equity’s how I grew up. So I like to understand that level of financeable cash flow.
The other thing that I would say, Barry, is I do like to understand with real precision what specific problem this company is solving. Because one thing I do see in my deal flow—I know you probably do too—there are some very exciting and interesting technologies out there, and they’re fabulous science experiments and great ideas. But is there a way to actually commercialize it? Is there a real business that can come out of it? And I’ve actually been surprised at how many young companies have been able to raise some money, often through friends and family, because there’s a novelty to what they’re producing, but I haven’t been able to get my mind around their ability to scale. Similarly, at the opposite end, even when it’s investing in one of these mature businesses, I want to know what the next chapter of growth can be for this company. It’s not enough for it to just have stasis. What is it that it can do to transform its trajectory?
[00:29:08] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So you co-invest along with Alexis Ohanian’s 776. Ohanian was behind Reddit, if I remember.
[00:29:17] ANN BERRY: He was the co-founder of Reddit. And just to clarify, 776 is this VC fund, and he’s married to the fabulous Serena Williams, right? 776 had a program called the Titans Program. And so what 776 did, very graciously, was write a check to me and say, “You have full discretion on how to invest this.” So it truly is backing with a capital B. And so the investments I’ve made there have been very interesting. It includes a business called Teal Health, which is an at-home cervical cancer test, so that women don’t need to go to their doctors and have those very uncomfortable tests. They can do it at home. It provides access, by the way, to women in rural areas where there aren’t enough doctors locally to help them. That’s an example of a consumer health business that I invested in.
Another one is a deepfake detection company called Reality Defender—that was an investment I made before deepfakes were grabbing the headlines. So I was lucky to invest in that business, which originally was backed by Eric Schmidt. Those are the kinds of examples of the technology businesses that I’ve invested behind.
[00:30:21] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I’m trying to remember, there was a professor at Dartmouth who did a deepfake detection company. I don’t know if that’s Reality Defender or—
[00:30:29] ANN BERRY: This one’s a little different, but it’s been around for about six years. It’s done incredibly well at science and big corporate partnerships. Gartner identified it as the leader in terms of the emerging technology companies looking to tackle this space. And it’s just getting more and more important.
[00:30:46] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So when you’re looking at a private investment, either a startup or a private equity investment, how do you separate where the value creation is going to come from? Is it improving the business? Is it leverage? Is it a higher exit valuation? There are so many different ways capital and advice can improve a situation. Are those all distinct? Is it all, you know, door-to-door combat? Every investment is somewhat different.
[00:31:16] ANN BERRY: Every investment is somewhat different. I would say, within the buckets that you just described, the days of financial engineering and only financial engineering have been gone for a long time. There has to be a clear value creation plan. There has to be an operational plan that provides line of sight. What is it you can do to drive incremental revenue growth? What is it you can do to streamline overhead? What is it you can do to get your margins up? What is it you can do about your value proposition and how you articulate it to your clients to make sure that you can take price in a consistent way? What are you doing to try to make sure that you are finding adjacencies that you can move into to expand your addressable market? All of those are critical. Yes, you need the right financing. Yes, you need to structure it appropriately. But I don’t think we’re at a point anymore, Barry, that higher valuations at exit can be expected unless you’ve actually done something to the business fundamentally to justify the change in that valuation outlook—which, to me, comes back to the operational enhancements and the execution needed to deliver on them.
[00:32:16] BARRY RITHOLTZ: You know, I’m a couple of decades older than you, so I have very vivid recollection of seeing various companies pop up in the nineties and then either get steamrolled by Microsoft in some cases, or just newer, better technology that bypassed whatever they were doing. And I’ve started to notice the same thing happening with AI: these new companies come along and say, “We’re going to do this,” and it’s like, no, no, Claude does that. I don’t need you. Or, “Here’s our value proposition,” and you go to ChatGPT, “Hey, can you do something in this space?” How challenging is this environment, if artificial intelligence potentially is so disruptive to what looks like promising startups?
[00:33:10] ANN BERRY: Back to why I still love those mature businesses that have been around from what seems like the dawn of time. Look, I think from the startup side there are still real opportunities. I mentioned I’ve invested in Yann LeCun’s recent startup, AMI, and he’s focused on world models. Are you familiar with world models, Barry?
[00:33:25] BARRY RITHOLTZ: World models?
[00:33:25] ANN BERRY: So in a nutshell, if we think about ChatGPT and we think about Claude, which I use enormously, as I’m sure you do, these large language models have been trained for the most part on written text, right? We’ve also now, in the world of generative AI, got visuals and pictures and videos. But text has really been the core. That’s why they’re called LLMs. World models move into the idea of AI being able to understand the three-dimensional or multidimensional physical world—
[00:33:57] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Important for robotics and things like that.
[00:33:58] ANN BERRY: Exactly. And I was lucky that several years ago I sort of heard enough about world models that I was actually looking actively for an opportunity to start investing in them. And I’d invested with the group behind this particular raise back in 2014, before AI was a thing. It used to be called predictive analytics. You remember big data. And none of that truly meant AI, in terms of the same kind of ability to generate. But the idea of the merits of huge repositories of data, and inference and prediction, has been around a lot longer than the last five years. Well—
[00:34:32] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Well, we could go back to—what was it, Big Blue and the chess competition? And then what was the model behind Jeopardy?
[00:34:42] ANN BERRY: Go. Go is a big one.
[00:34:43] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Remember, Go is a giant one, which is a simple but very nuanced, complex game. So versions, predecessors to AI have certainly been around for decades. It’s just become—it is the future. Star Trek promised it fifty years ago.
[00:34:59] ANN BERRY: In a format the consumer understands. And that’s what’s caught mindshare, and that’s what’s caught attention, and that’s what’s caused proliferation that people get behind. I think it’s not just B2B anymore, or not just a nerd like me getting excited about what this data could be. But to go back to your original question, Barry, there’s absolutely space for startups who can move faster, who can be more nimble, who can be quicker in using AI to create, I think, niche products. And then they become fabulous targets, acquisition targets, for some of the bigger scaled players.
Where I find opportunity exists—and I’m frustrated that not all big companies have capitalized on it—is that so many businesses are sitting on huge troves of data on their hardware. Not everyone’s in the cloud, right? It’s sitting there on their on-premise ERP systems that haven’t gone to the cloud yet. Or we can take something that is more virtual, and it’s a public stock that’s frustrated me: PayPal. It baffles my mind that PayPal, with its scale and its first-mover advantage, has not done more, faster, with the sheer amount of historical transaction data and consumer immersion sitting there. That’s the kind of business you—
[00:36:16] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Should do. Well, you look at what happened with Stripe and with Square, which I think is now Block, and—
[00:36:20] ANN BERRY: And BNPL came out, right? And—
[00:36:22] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Took traction, and a whole bunch of things kind of leapfrogged over. I mean, I remember when they were just the processor for eBay. Thirty—
[00:36:30] ANN BERRY: That’s right. Years ago it—
[00:36:31] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Feels like. So sometimes you can become a victim of your own success. Hey, isn’t that Crossing the Chasm? Isn’t that the innovator’s dilemma, that your success plants a seed for your eventual failure?
[00:36:47] ANN BERRY: It can anchor you. That being said, if you have success and you have the wherewithal to figure out how to use that success as a way in which to leapfrog the next person, I think that’s where there’s opportunity. You know, January 2022, Barry, I wrote a piece. I published it on LinkedIn, I talked about it on CNBC, and the name of the piece I wrote was “A Tech Stock by Any Other Name Is Walmart.” And the reason I wrote that was I was starting to see in Walmart’s filings—as a business I’d been obsessed with for ages—them starting to talk about this ad business that was sort of hiding inside it. Walmart, in its transcripts and its filings, was starting to talk about all of the data it was getting from its e-commerce platform, and growing demand by brands to figure out how to get in front of clients or consumers beyond just social media, ’cause it was getting expensive now just to have campaigns on Facebook or Instagram. And so I wrote this piece to call attention to the fact that here was Walmart—some called them a dinosaur, a dinosaur many people love—but it had woken up to the fact that it had a gem inside of its massive business, which was data. Fast forward to today, it’s a nearly six-and-a-half-billion-dollar revenue part of the business. And it moved its listing to Nasdaq to really hammer home the idea that Walmart believes itself now to be a tech company.
[00:38:09] BARRY RITHOLTZ: That’s really interesting. I used to think of them as a logistics company. Were they chasing what Amazon had done in that space prior, or was it truly their own innovation? By the way, my favorite data point on Walmart is they are the single biggest deployer of solar panels—
[00:38:28] ANN BERRY: That’s interesting.
[00:38:29] BARRY RITHOLTZ: —in the country, ’cause they just have endless giant flat stores, giant flat warehouses primarily. At least they used to be primarily in the Sunbelt. They’ve expanded, obviously, everywhere, but the single biggest consumer of solar energy, with a dramatic reduction in energy consumption costs.
[00:38:47] ANN BERRY: It’s interesting, too. I remember researching virtual reality headsets and Oculus—and someone should fact-check me on this, but the time I looked at this a couple of years ago, Walmart had trained a million store associates using VR headsets and Oculus for things like role play, dealing with a difficult customer, or figuring out how to stack shelves more safely. Talk about adopting technology at scale. That’s the kind of thing where, you know, these big companies may be in danger of being leapfrogged, but they’re also there with the potential to grab new technology and do new things with it if they have the wherewithal to do so. So—
[00:39:22] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I’m curious about the potential backlash, and I’ll give you two examples. One is, you know, I’ve been an Amazon customer since I got my first gift certificate from a college roommate in the late nineties. But now Walmart advertising is a giant business, and it’s completely degraded the experience as a consumer, to the point where I’m searching for a specific lithium battery for a key fob and I have the model number, 7435. Why are you showing me an ad? It used to be you would click on the first thing that pops up, and that’s the 7435 BMW key fob, or whatever it was at the time. And your advertiser—okay, so great, you got eleven cents for that ad. I ordered this; it’s the wrong one. And if I’m searching for 7435, I’m going to return it, because I want it to cost you money so you stop serving the wrong ads. Generally speaking, there’s literally an entire book on the—and I’m using the—
[00:40:33] ANN BERRY: That’s not actually the title of that.
[00:40:37] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I’m using the polite, PG-rated version: “enification.” At what point is there a backlash brewing to that sort of stuff? And then perhaps the more modern—and I think the ad stuff is already ten years old—the more modern example of that is, are we just going to have an arms race between stuff like dynamic pricing, where, “Oh, we can read your zip code off your license plate and we’re going to charge you more for a Big Mac”? Ever since we started seeing a lot more of that with a company like Uber, all right: it’s the same car, it’s the same driver, I’m going to take Lyft, and it’s 40% less. What is the risk?
Torsten Slok of Apollo just wrote, “Hey, how long is it going to be before various agentic—like Facebook’s Muse and other agents—are going to say, ‘Hey, find out where the highest-paying money market is. My big money center bank gives me a quarter percent interest. Move the money to Schwab or Fidelity or wherever, get me five percent, and as soon as this is competitive, move it back’?” I mean, at a certain point some of these games are just going to alienate customers or force an arms race.
[00:41:57] ANN BERRY: So there’s a lot to unpack, and there are lots of questions within that. So let’s start with the last one, because what you just described is businesses with dynamic pricing. The not-favored word for that is “price discrimination”—or the ultimate expression of personalization, which is something consumers have long believed to be wanting to have. Well, you just described, Barry, though—if you had an agent that you could deploy to look around for you and find the place to stash your money that’s going to get the highest return for you, I don’t think you would have a backlash against that use of AI. Is that fair, as a consumer?
[00:42:36] BARRY RITHOLTZ: As a consumer, absolutely.
[00:42:36] ANN BERRY: You wouldn’t. So that’s a case where AI could be proven to help the consumer, different from the first example you gave, of the “enification” of things like ads, where in that instance the AI is not working to serve up what you want. And I think there are two different issues. I think there are companies out there—I invested in one of them, actually, a business called Vodi—which went to one of the big e-commerce platforms and typed into their search engine, “I want to find, you know, a red sofa,” or “a red sofa with buttons.” And the quality of the feed, the search results that came back, was just really, really poor. And what founder Stephanie Chesky did was build this company, Vodi, to work with retailers to say, “You’ve got to get your platforms better. Consumers don’t want to be served up the wrong answer to their searches. They want you—”
[00:43:30] BARRY RITHOLTZ: To understand what you mean. Well, if you run it through ads, it seems like search and advertising have an inherent conflict: we want people scrolling through pages of results, with ads being served alongside it, or we’re going to show you whoever pays the most for an ad, which may not be the best fit for what you’re searching for. How do you resolve that? To me, I’m going to bet that some states—probably California, New York, and then it spreads—are going to outlaw dynamic pricing in supermarkets. When you price a dozen eggs, it shouldn’t be able to figure out who you are, what the—
[00:44:10] ANN BERRY: Credit score.
[00:44:11] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Right. There was something Walmart was working on, where they’ll charge you more for mayonnaise if the cart you’re driving around with senses you already have tuna fish in your cart. That sort of stuff. This is what the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau—that was more or less gutted under this presidency—was supposed to stop. If you think inflation is bad now, wait till these license plate readers and AI max out. It’s going to add 30, 40% to the price of goods, unless there’s either legislation or an arms race with consumer AI saying, “No, thank you.”
[00:44:57] ANN BERRY: And people vote with their feet. And they say, “I don’t want to deal with this.”
[00:45:00] BARRY RITHOLTZ: There’s inertia, but eventually, yes. But there’s still—look, I think a lot of people discovered during the pandemic that there are retailers worth sharing your credit card with. For the longest time, Amazon was clearly the low-price provider. Not only is that no longer the case, it’s not even remotely close to the case. But there was a TV I wanted to buy that I thought was kind of exorbitant, and Claude just alerted me, “Hey, it’s on sale, $500 less at Amazon.” Hey, fantastic. Are we going to have dynamic pricing versus agentic consumer apps?
[00:45:44] ANN BERRY: I don’t think it’s one versus the other necessarily. One of the things I will share with you, which was interesting: I was moderating at the World Department Store Summit in Mexico City earlier this—
[00:45:57] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Year, where, by the way, they’re building giant data centers along the border.
[00:46:02] ANN BERRY: Huge, huge data centers. And one of the things that the CEO of Liverpool, which is a big department store there, talked about was how consumer products companies and retailers are going to have to figure out how to market to agents in the same way that they’ve been figuring out how to market to consumers. Isn’t that fascinating? That is—
[00:46:22] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Absolutely—
[00:46:22] ANN BERRY: Fascinating. ’Cause exactly, using the example you gave, Barry, if an agent is now purchasing on your behalf, how do you make sure the agent can find the product that the product producer wants to have found quickly? So I think we’ve got that coming. I think we’ve got a shift in how the retailers and the consumer products companies figure out how they’re going to be found the quickest, with the data that they want to control and relay, by these agents who are doing shopping on behalf of consumers.
[00:46:50] BARRY RITHOLTZ: It truly is fascinating. “May you live in interesting times” is considered a curse, but I find interesting times utterly fascinating. And there’s always something new and different to learn. Coming up, we continue our conversation with Ann Berry, founder and managing partner of Threadneedle, talking about the current venture and IPO landscape. I’m Barry Ritholtz, and you’re listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio.
I’m Barry Ritholtz. You’re listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio. Ann Berry is the founder and managing partner at Threadneedle. They provide both advice and capital to high-growth companies at various stages of their life cycle, from seed to A and B rounds to private equity to established companies. So we’ve been talking about AI. I’m legally obligated to discuss these things, but I’m fascinated by it. You cover very heavy AI infrastructure spending on your show all the time, on your podcast. How do you respond to all these accusations of, “Hey, this is a bubble,” or it’s circular financing, or the spending isn’t justified? What’s your reaction to those sorts of commentaries?
[00:48:13] ANN BERRY: My reaction is they’re all legitimate concerns. And I raise that when I’m having interviews with CEOs of big companies in the space, Barry. And the reason I feel that way is not because I don’t believe in the promise of AI. I absolutely do, ’cause I see it in the early stages, from the most innovative to the most scaled. But as somebody who also spends a lot of time looking at public markets, trained by the discipline of looking at return on investment that comes from growing up in the private capital world, when you go and look at the earnings transcripts, or listen to the earnings calls, or look at the presentations, or even read the analyst research, there is just not a ton of rigor at the moment in being able to wrap one’s arms around what is the real return that’s being expected on these CapEx dollars. Now, the analogy that people give is the internet age—the dawn of the internet.
[00:49:09] BARRY RITHOLTZ: That’s a terrible comparison.
[00:49:10] ANN BERRY: Tell me why you say that.
[00:49:11] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Well, these are real companies. You talk about path to cash flow—pets.com is the epitome of that space. And twenty years later you have Chewy, which is what pets.com could have been. It just was too costly then. Now these companies have scale, they have revenue, some even have profits. Plus, with the internet, we had a sense of what the internet was going to do, and it was connected, but we had print and we had video and other related things that the internet just made a whole lot more accessible. This feels very much like an order of magnitude—like an Industrial Revolution–like change that’s happening a hundred times faster. And of course there’ll be misallocation of capital, like there always is with every tech innovation. But a lot of things got funded during the internet. It wasn’t just that they didn’t work out; they were barely wisps of an idea. It seems that what’s getting funded are real things with real potential, and in many cases actual revenue. We can argue about $2 trillion market caps. Clearly that’s a giant number for a technology that we don’t know how profitable it’ll ultimately be.
[00:50:35] ANN BERRY: And that is my point, Barry. We are in the world of tangible market caps. These are tangible numbers being tied to non-tangible—at least right now—returns. We know that there is going to be an outcome that’s tangible. It’s the measurability that we are not able to see. That, to me, is where the concern lies. It’s not whether the underlying technology will be transformational; I believe it will be. But how transformational, and when, is where the math becomes very difficult to unpack when you start looking at these valuations.
I would just want to finish the thought: the one place I am seeing discipline is actually with the earlier-stage companies. If you roll back—do you remember 2021, 2022?—anything that was an NFT or Web3 was getting crazy valuations. I’m not seeing that lack of discipline right now, which I do take some comfort from when it comes to early-stage investing.
[00:51:27] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Other than AI—OpenAI and Anthropic and, arguably, SpaceX—there’s a great chart floating around that shows those three IPOs are going to be worth more than every technology IPO from 1980 to—
[00:51:42] ANN BERRY: 2025.
[00:51:43] BARRY RITHOLTZ: That’s right. So that really raises a question. And sure, you have to inflation-adjust it, but even still, especially given the open source models that are out there—yes, there’s a concern that they’re from China and there are security issues—how long is it going to be before a couple of open source models gain traction that are domestic, founded in the US by former Anthropic, OpenAI, Microsoft, Google, whatever? And what does that mean to the profitability of these mega companies? If Google Docs is free—they never got rid of Microsoft Office. There were a whole bunch of open source operating systems. I mean, Linux underlies a whole bunch of stuff, but Microsoft Windows seems to have done okay over the years. So I don’t know if open source is a genuine threat to these, but it’s certainly a factor you have to think about.
[00:52:44] ANN BERRY: Right. I think overseas open source is something to look at. And, you know, I travel extensively globally, and it’s always interesting to me to look at technologies that are being received a certain way in the US and then look overseas to see how they’re being adopted, and which international non-US companies are gaining scale outside the US market. So, for example, if you go to Mexico City, or you go to parts of Africa, it’s Chinese EVs everywhere. If you go to parts of the world that are not Europe or the United States, DeepSeek and the Chinese models are getting rapidly adopted because it’s free. And even the paid versions are going to be much, much cheaper than the paid versions being produced by OpenAI and Anthropic and Google. So—
[00:53:36] BARRY RITHOLTZ: So I know I wouldn’t want to give DeepSeek access to my investing or bank account.
[00:53:42] ANN BERRY: But you would give it to Claude.
[00:53:44] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I would be more inclined to give it to Claude. So Claude now has access to my calendar and email. I let it create drafts, not send them out.
[00:53:54] ANN BERRY: Instead of Gemini.
[00:53:56] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Gemini—I use NotebookLM. If I want to upload a PDF of a book or something and say—this is a whole ’nother conversation. But the way I like to use AI is to do the first draft myself, and then to ask it independently for a draft, and then to combine the two and say, “Take the best of both.” And it’s still like 80/20 or 70/30 me. But I’ve watched it shift. I’ve watched it go from mostly human to collaborative. I try not to be transactional. I try to be collaborative with it. So I use NotebookLM, which is a Google product, for: here’s a 400-page PDF, give me the best data points, give me the best quotes from the author, or anybody. And I’ve read the book. What do you think is the most interesting theme that comes out of this? And sometimes you get a really intelligent answer, and sometimes you get, “Oh, you still don’t understand the nuances here.” But it continues to improve. Every time, it’s a little better. A little—
[00:54:58] ANN BERRY: Better. Oh, you’re training it. You’re getting it there. And at least you understand.
[00:55:01] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Well, I’ve been training these for—well, Claude for a year, and Gemini for, I don’t know, NotebookLM for six months. I think I started over the summer. I’m training it, but they’re also improving very rapidly.
[00:55:17] ANN BERRY: Well, I think, to your question on can there be a new company that comes out of one of the behemoths that we see today and leapfrogs, I think what we’re seeing, Barry, is they’re getting scooped up and acquired pretty quickly, right? So when I talk about the world models thesis that I have—I believe in this for robotics; I’ve invested in industrial tech for a while—Fei-Fei Li had her world models company just bought by AMD, right? The ability of the OpenAIs and the Anthropics to raise capital—because at the end of the day there’s almost a flight to scale, right? I wouldn’t call it safety, but there’s a flight to scale—is arming these folks with war chests that they’re using to go out and scoop up anything that could be a contender—
[00:55:59] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Flight to enterprise.
[00:56:00] ANN BERRY: Is what it seems—flight to enterprise. Great way to put it.
[00:56:03] BARRY RITHOLTZ: You know, when we look at the concentration in the Mag Seven that everybody complains about, it’s not seven companies. It’s a thousand companies. They’ve been doing acquisitions for twenty-five years. Really, we haven’t seen the sort of antitrust enforcement since Reagan was in office that would have prevented all that from happening. So now it’s just a whole different business sector that’s scaling up. Look at how many businesses Google owns. Google owns YouTube. Look at Microsoft, look at Apple, and then look at this giant media acquisition. Can you still get innovation from these behemoths? Is it just going to bubble up, and these companies get acquired? What does that mean for the innovation economy? What does that mean for the startup economy? And most importantly, what does it mean to you as an investor?
[00:56:55] ANN BERRY: Well, as an investor, I can start by saying I find it exciting, because it means your exit opportunity feels, at the moment, to be pretty robust—
[00:57:03] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Not an IPO. More likely than an—
[00:57:04] ANN BERRY: Acquisition, not an IPO. Correct. And we’ve still got corporations that have big cash balances. That’s been true for a while. Some have given their capital back to shareholders through buyback programs or by hiking their dividends, but they want to buy. And you know what’s so interesting, Barry? When I’ve interviewed CEOs and CFOs of these big public tech companies, I can’t help myself, I ask the question: what is your criteria for doing an acquisition? And I hear everything. The technology’s the right fit. There’s product adjacency. It’s got a great team. It’s going to fit our culture. Boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. I don’t hear price until I ask about it. I have to say, “But what about valuation?” Well, you know—
[00:57:45] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Let me name-drop a second.
[00:57:46] ANN BERRY: Please.
[00:57:47] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I got to interview Marc Andreessen eight, ten years ago in their Palo Alto office, and I asked about valuation. And he’s like, “You know, we are in the business of lots of failures and the occasional home run.” And so he goes, “People thought we were crazy when we put all this money into Facebook. We could have paid double; it wouldn’t have made any difference.”
[00:58:16] ANN BERRY: Difference.
[00:58:16] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Right. If you’re looking for a 50- to 100-x—well, at a certain point, and maybe $2 trillion for an IPO is that point, I don’t know, but at a certain point, it seems the valuation, if you’re a hundred-billion-dollar-and-up company, what’s fifty or a hundred million dollars here or there? It almost is irrelevant. Am I overstating the no-valuation point?
[00:58:43] ANN BERRY: I don’t think you are. And these are companies that have historically been known for discipline, right—defined as a very clear sense of what their return on investment has to be with these acquisitions. And they’re now saying being in the game is more important than valuing the game.
The other piece we’re seeing, Barry, which I find fascinating, is that some of the biggest venture capital firms in the United States now are corporates that are investing their balance sheets into startups. And in some cases it’s paid off. You know, NVIDIA has a big stake in SpaceX. Last earnings season, there was a lot of coverage. You see the news—the FT was covering what proportion of these public companies’ earnings were coming from the markups, the writeups, and the valuation of some of these AI businesses as they prepare to go—
[00:59:26] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Public. It’s really one-time—
[00:59:27] ANN BERRY: Charges, which are one-time bumps, or one-time—
[00:59:29] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Markups, as opposed to ongoing. You can’t do one of those a week. There’s only—
[00:59:35] ANN BERRY: Only so many. But you look at NVIDIA, you look at Salesforce, you look at the balance sheets of these companies, and you see how much they have invested in startups. Even if you take out the markups and just look at the underlying cost basis, billions of dollars deployed in funding young companies in their ecosystems. I mean, it’s absolutely extraordinary. And, by the way, a smart M&A tactic, right? Because you’re basically looking at a potential acquisition target as it grows up within your sphere of influence.
[01:00:02] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Before I get to my favorite questions, I just have to ask you a little bit about the media background. Not only that you host a podcast and have been writing about stuff for years, but how has the platform built around Jimmy Kimmel, Wheelhouse—how did that kind of nudge you into looking at media a little differently, almost as an extension of what you do as an investor?
[01:00:31] ANN BERRY: So at the time that I joined Wheelhouse—and Jimmy was much more involved there than he is today, so I should just clarify that it was at a moment in time—this was 2021 when I joined. And the words “creator economy” were really taking flight. You remember this, Barry? Everyone was talking about—one version was Kim Kardashian wanting to raise a private equity fund. Another was NFTs. You’re grimacing as I say that—
[01:00:57] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Grimacing—the finfluencers is just—
[01:01:01] ANN BERRY: Well, that’s a different—we’re happy to talk about that too. But the creator economy. And so for the short period of time that I was there, it was a really excellent education on how important content is now for so many businesses. You have your own business, Barry. I’ve no doubt the fact that you host this wonderful podcast is helpful to you.
[01:01:25] BARRY RITHOLTZ: We have a giant media footprint that my partners and I have built over ten years. And for us, we started out with my media footprint and clients coming to us as opposed to the other way around. And it worked. So we just continually built on that.
[01:01:45] ANN BERRY: I did see that there at Wheelhouse—and I think they were ahead of the curve in thinking about this—and I’ve seen since then with my own media endeavors, there is a flywheel: content builds an audience. Now, an audience does not necessarily translate directly into a consumer, by the way. It’s a process. It doesn’t always work. So we are speaking at a moment in time where Scarlett Johansson has just announced that her beauty brand is shuttering, right? So that’s an example of where celebrity and an audience and fandom does not necessarily translate into consistent consumer purchasing habits. But enough of it does exist in some places that one of the things I now look at in terms of execution, to come back to that, if I’m investing in a consumer-facing business, is that I do want to understand what their content strategy is. Not just traditional paid media, you know, not just the same old campaigns on social media, right? Is the founder story being told—should it be—in a way that’s not a big distraction for the founder from running their business? Are there collaborations that should be done with content creators to amplify them? Is the marketing team thinking more creatively and expansively about what it is to put together their marketing campaign, which includes working with creators? So it was an incredibly good period working with Wheelhouse, to get educated and to learn about what works and what doesn’t in the world where it overlaps.
[01:03:10] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Super interesting. I only have you for another ten minutes, so let’s jump to our speed round. Starting with—you’ve mentioned some of your mentors. Tell us about the people who helped shape your career.
[01:03:24] ANN BERRY: Can I go back to high school? It’s a slightly quirky one, because you go—
[01:03:27] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Back to wherever.
[01:03:28] ANN BERRY: Wherever. Because you are very well read, Barry, and I think you’ll appreciate what I’m about to say. When I was a couple of years into my career on Wall Street, I actually wrote a letter to my high school English literature teacher, a woman called Naomi Rich, and said I was always good at math, and I really enjoyed English lit. And I said, “Actually, if I look at what was the best training for my career in investing, hands down, it was English literature.” Having to look at a poem I’d never read before, or a piece of prose I’d never read before, or a book—what you have to do is decide what you infer from what you’re reading, come up with a point of view around how it’s resonating with you, and then articulate in a structured way, in an essay, with a beginning, middle, and end, how it’s landed for you. Why cite elements, use quotations, prove your case. Doesn’t that sound to you like putting together an investment committee memo?
[01:04:22] BARRY RITHOLTZ: That is a classic syllogism, where, hey, look at this set of data, facts, words; figure out what the theme is, and then apply it to this new situation—
[01:04:33] ANN BERRY: And be persuasive to someone.
[01:04:35] BARRY RITHOLTZ: That’s true across so many different fields. A hundred percent. So your high school English teacher—
[01:04:40] ANN BERRY: Yes, in an unexpected way. But there were others. When I was starting out in private equity at Goldman in London—I mentioned some other Goldman folks I worked with—Sanjay Patel was co-running the group. I was in the merchant bank in London. He went on to run Apollo International. And he was a great influence. You know, he said, “Go to business school, have fun, don’t mess up, have fun.” And he said something interesting to me. He said, “People who go to graduate school wanting to network intentionally get it all wrong. Don’t be that person with a BlackBerry”—the BlackBerries then. You know, there are people like that, giving out business cards.
[01:05:16] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Let it be organic, not—
[01:05:17] ANN BERRY: Forced. Make friends. I was twenty-four years old. It’s like, go have a blast. Make friends, do your studies, and take it seriously. He said, because you’ll be surprised: twenty years after graduation, people are still going to remember, were you a clown in class, or were you actually a serious person who they actually wanted to listen to in class? Which I thought was very interesting. He also gave me great career advice. Gail Mandel was on my board when I was running the laundry business. She was the CEO of Wyndham Destinations—unbelievable woman, fabulous execution, grown up as a CFO, and during a crisis was there every second of every day, very senior and hands-on. And then I do want to shout out Larry Bossidy—
[01:05:59] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Of course.
[01:06:00] ANN BERRY: Who was the CEO of AlliedSignal. And he too was an advisor in my first CEO gig, and, Barry, he was unfailingly in my corner. He would call me every week like clockwork.
[01:06:13] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I’m not being rude, I’m checking something.
[01:06:15] ANN BERRY: Please do. He sadly passed away last summer, which I was devastated by. But unbelievable execution—cared about his people, was a great mentor to me. Constantly pushed me with two questions. “Are you still growing?” And I’d say, “Larry, no, I’m still five foot two. Last time you saw me.” And when I was thinking about a new endeavor, including when I was thinking about doing more in media or starting my own business, he said, “Do you think it will be successful?” And he was unbelievably good about framing: what does success mean, and what would it take for something to achieve that predefined success? And he was very generous with his time and wisdom with me.
[01:06:58] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Let’s talk about books. What are some of your favorites? What are you reading currently?
[01:07:01] ANN BERRY: So, one of my favorites—I read it a couple of years ago, but I always have it close by—Andrew Roberts’s biography of Winston Churchill. I mean, I carried the hard copy of that book to the beach, Barry. I was so devoted to reading it.
[01:07:01] BARRY RITHOLTZ: It was a great book, which I really read. That is not a beach read.
[01:07:16] ANN BERRY: Well, but it’s a fabulous read in any location. So I recommend that one. There’s a book by a Bloomberg journalist whom I admire greatly. Katrina Manson wrote a book called Project Maven, which is about the use of AI in the Pentagon and the way in which AI has been adopted by the military. Fabulous read. It came out this year, and I strongly recommend it. And Sebastian Mallaby, because I know you are Mr. AI—
[01:07:40] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Sure. I’ve had him on a couple of times.
[01:07:41] ANN BERRY: The Infinity Machine. Great read. And I think the challenge is AI is moving so quickly, the book publication cycle doesn’t quite keep up with how quickly the tech is moving. But I think they’re good foundational pieces, so I would start there. There’s one other book too: The Algorithm, by John McNeill.
[01:07:59] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I’ve heard of it.
[01:08:00] ANN BERRY: John McNeill was the president of Tesla. He wrote a book called The Algorithm that talked about how a business like Tesla was able to move at such speed with such scale. And it’s all about execution.
[01:08:11] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Besides books—since you host a podcast, I’m curious, what podcasts do you listen to outside of finance or anything else? You’re streaming Netflix, Amazon, what have you?
[01:08:23] ANN BERRY: Well, I listen to a lot of Bloomberg. It’s my go-to for news. So congratulations to you for contributing to that here, Barry. I gotta tell you, and it’s an awful confession to make, but I’m going to make it, for someone who appears on content and invests around it a lot: I spend most of my time with people in real life, if I’m honest. I travel a lot, for both passion and work. And for me, listening to a podcast, I’m going to have a conversation with a person.
[01:08:53] BARRY RITHOLTZ: You are not the first person in our space to say that, because you’re doing research, you’re prepping, you’re running your day job.
[01:09:01] ANN BERRY: I’m absorbing business content all the time.
[01:09:04] BARRY RITHOLTZ: And then, right. So I always have queues on my phone of podcasts to listen to. And when it becomes homework, I just start deleting it. But it’s hard to access that when you’re so busy doing other stuff and creating your own content.
[01:09:21] ANN BERRY: The algo’s smart, though. It feeds me, even on Netflix or Apple, fictional stuff that seems to tie in with my business perspective. So, have you watched Silo?
[01:09:31] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I—
[01:09:31] ANN BERRY: It’s fantastic.
[01:09:32] BARRY RITHOLTZ: I can’t get my wife to sit down and watch it. We’ve tried.
[01:09:35] ANN BERRY: Well, tell her it’s a can-do woman who’s getting things done and leading in a way that you wouldn’t.
[01:09:40] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Same with Pluribus on Apple.
[01:09:42] ANN BERRY: Which I haven’t seen yet. I haven’t—
[01:09:43] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Seen either, but everybody recommends Silo. And if you like that, you—
[01:09:47] ANN BERRY: Should see The Diplomat. That’s the other one. Of course.
[01:09:49] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Well, that’s fantastic—
[01:09:50] ANN BERRY: Because I’m NYLON. I’m New York, London.
[01:09:51] BARRY RITHOLTZ: There’s a fourth or a fifth season coming out. I think it’s been greenlit.
[01:09:54] ANN BERRY: And there’s one other that’s similar. I don’t remember if it was The Agency or The Diplomat, but some of our go-tos—
[01:10:03] BARRY RITHOLTZ: They’re coming back.
[01:10:04] ANN BERRY: New seasons, right. September, October, November, they’re coming out.
[01:10:04] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Our final two questions. What sort of advice would you give to a recent college grad interested in a career in either M&A, venture and startup investing, private equity, or media?
[01:10:21] ANN BERRY: I would say, go get your hands dirty with AI. And frankly, that extends, Barry, to any young person now trying to get into the workforce. And just to tell you a quick story, this applies to everybody. There’s one company I’m on the board of, and I said to folks, “What are you doing in AI?” And I got some feedback. I said, “Here’s what’s going to happen. Everyone has to do their Claude 101 certificate and send it back to me,” because I could just tell that some very senior folks weren’t getting their hands dirty. They were waiting for someone else to tell them, “This is what it looks like and this is what it can do.” I think a young person in college now is at such an advantage, because I think they’re probably more innately wired to experiment with these tools, to intuit what they’re capable of, to see into the future and what they’re able to do. I would say, go master them and be ready to come in and teach your colleagues how to use it and be the go-to person on adoption.
[01:11:15] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Our final question: what do you know about the world of startup, venture, private equity investing today that would’ve been useful twenty, twenty-five years ago when you were first getting started?
[01:11:26] ANN BERRY: I would come back to what I’ve said, which is: get experience in the broader world. You know, finance is a pretty narrow place, at least the skills that you learn starting out. You tend to be in one organization, you are looking at one deal at a time, you are learning almost one skill at a time. AI will change that. But it wasn’t, frankly, until I got to graduate school and met people who’d served in the military, or went from having lots of finance-only friends to people who’d run big P&Ls as marketing managers at consumer packaged goods businesses. I would say, go out there, be curious, travel, meet lots of different kinds of people. Try to work inside a company to learn what it is truly like to be accountable inside and beholden to your capital providers. And then come back to finance, or go into finance, knowing that the numbers are just a representation of the world out there. And get that context.
[01:12:20] BARRY RITHOLTZ: Really super interesting. Ann, thank you for being so generous with your time. We have been speaking with Ann Berry. She’s founder and managing partner at Threadneedle.
If you enjoy this conversation, well, check out any of the 672 we’ve done over the past twelve years. You can find those at Bloomberg, Apple, Spotify, YouTube, wherever you find your favorite podcasts. I would be remiss if I didn’t thank the crack staff that helps put these conversations together each week. Sam Danzinger is our video producer, Anna Luke is my audio producer, Noah Friedman is my podcast producer.
~~~
The post Transcript: Ann Berry, Threadneedle Founder & CIO on Providing Capital to Tech Companies: appeared first on The Big Picture .