Letters to the Editor, October 12th: On Wednesday’s strike, prisoner rehabilitation and growing fruit and veg
Sir, – There will be no Dáil sitting on Wednesday as more than 100,000 public sector workers prepare to take part in a nationwide strike over pay (“ Dáil sitting next Wednesday cancelled due public sector workers’ strike ”, News, October 10th). Let me get this one right: the Government has decided they won’t turn up for work on Wednesday because of the strikes? I find it difficult to comprehend that our politicians have made such a decision. Our TDs should display leadership by turning up for work, especially when a lot of this imbroglio is of their own making. – Yours, etc, JOHN O’BRIEN, Clonmel, Co Tipperary. GAA’s attitude to women Sir, – I have just read Malachy Clerkin’s article on the GAA’s attitude to women (“ Mary McAleese questioned the GAA’s attitude towards women – now they’ve replaced her with a man ”, Sport, October 9th). Please readers, save it and pass it around. It should be compulsory reading and subject for discussion for all GAA club members and, indeed, for the public. – Yours, etc, JOHN JOHNSTON-KEHOE, Dunmore Road, Waterford. Imported fruit and vegetables Sir, – Ireland’s dependence on imported fruit and vegetables, as described by Cian O’Connell, reflects a food system that makes it difficult for growers to earn a living and leaves too many people disconnected from how their food is grown (“ Why doesn’t Ireland grow more vegetables? ”, News, October 10th). Global shocks and a rapidly worsening biodiversity crisis should prompt us to rethink our export-focused model that leaves us short and that hurts both farmers and nature. Such a rethink requires an honest assessment of who benefits, and at what cost, from our current food system. A resilient and sustainable food system is about more than farming. It is about our relationship with food, nature and each other. Community gardens, for example, help people develop practical experience of how growing food together can promote wellbeing and resilience. These gardens cannot replace commercial horticulture, but they can help grow the connections and culture that make good food more accessible, and our communities more resilient, in an uncertain world. As we mark National Community Gardens and Allotments Week this week, maybe we can go beyond its stated aim of raising awareness of the benefits of urban growing spaces and initiate a nationwide debate on what food, not just agriculture, means to us all? – Yours, etc, HANS ZOMER, Ballymun, Dublin. Child deaths from malnutrition A chara, – I appreciate it is important to listen to all perspectives. However, hearing a consultant paediatrician (“ October 7th was a piercing, shrieking alarm call for all Jews ”, Opinion, October 9th) state that 119 children dying of malnutrition is a “thankfully low” number and due to “food-delivery efficacy”, when the Israeli government continues to block life-saving food and medical aid entering Gaza in a direct breach of international humanitarian law and basic morals, is deplorable. – Yours, etc, AISLING FLYNN, Sandymount, Dublin 4. Remembering Eddie Slovik Sir, – You report on the gross proposal of livestreaming of a military execution in the United States (“ Trump administration condemned for plans to livestream execution ”, World News, October 9th). It is mentioned in the report that “the last known cases of a military firing squad in the US was in November 1945″. It is worth noting that the soldier in question was Private Eddie Slovik, whose crime was desertion. He killed no one, in battle or elsewhere. His story was the subject of a moving film The Execution of Private Slovik (1974), with a young Martin Sheen as Slovik and giving one of his best performances. Though thousands deserted, he was made an example of even though the second World War had ended a few months before. I welcome the statement of the president of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Archbishop Paul S Coakley, who described the livestreaming idea as “a barbaric promotion of a culture of death”. He went on to say: “The public execution even of one who has done grave harm will only further undermine the moral fabric of our nation and be a blight on the conscience of its people.” Prophetic voices like this are sorely needed at this time. – Yours, etc, BRENDAN O’REGAN, Arklow, Co Wicklow. Sanctioning shame Sir, – As the US is now sanctioning the International Criminal Court (“ US sanctions International Criminal Court, hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize ”, World News, October 9th), is it not time for those who support the ICC to sanction the US? By standing by and doing nothing, do we share their shame? – Yours, etc, MONICA JOY, Celbridge, Co Kildare. Aggressive begging Sir, – Having spent some time in Dublin city centre recently, it is clear that aggressive begging is more widespread. This is a complex problem requiring myriad interventions. But it has become normalised and accepted here on a scale that you simply would not see in any comparable European city. Surely, the capital city of a country of our wealth and means can do better. Whatever the answer, the current approach – or lack of – is certainly not working. Yours, etc, ADAM LONG, Ballina, Co Tipperary. Government spending Sir, – Eoin Burke-Kennedy writes: “Norway knows when its tax windfall will end, Ireland doesn’t – yet we spend it anyway” “ There’s a good chance Ireland will come to regret this boomtime period as a missed opportunity ”, Business, October 9th). Two of the biggest contributors to our tax windfall could be hugely affected by the onward march of artificial intelligence (AI), yet our Government continues to live in this nirvana bubble. The Government has an obligation to those that elected it to spell out the consequences of continuous budget deficits and the probable impact of the disappearance of these tax windfalls. Necessary infrastructure spending needs to be clearly spelt out and how it is going to be financed and priorities need to clearly identified. So many areas need to be addressed – water, power, transport, health, housing, agriculture – and all these projects seem to be managed in a haphazard manner. There doesn’t appear to an integrated plan to identify timelines and resource requirements and how they are going to be financed. Yes, the Government is in a difficult political situation, but future generations will not forgive them if they ignore what the experts are telling them. – Yours, etc, VINCENT CARROLL, Rathfarnham, Dublin. Trump’s deal with Russia Sir, – Donald Trump’s deal with Vladimir Putin to buy Russian diesel undermines the integrity of the US as a peace mediator, removing any illusions that it acted as an honest broker between Ukraine and Russia (“ Trump agrees diesel supply deal with Russia ”, World News, October 9th). It is also the antithesis of the role that the US played in the process leading up to the Belfast Agreement . Back then, top-level political commitment by former US president Bill Clinton, combined with the competence of former US senator George Mitchell, played a constructive role in reaching the agreement and making peace. It was a prime example of the US exercising soft power rather than Trumpian bullying and threats. This chapter of US history deserves to be remembered and highlighted, not merely as a thing of the past, but as an inspiration for what is still possible. It is a message that Irish people on both sides of the Border could amplify by reminding the world of the time when America actually was great. – Yours, etc, OLIVER LOODE, Newcastle, Galway. Sir, – Donald Trump says Ukraine needs a new president (“US president Donald Trump says it is time for Ukraine to get rid of Zelenskiy”, World News, October 10th) If any country is in need of a new president it is the US and Russia; not Ukraine. Vladimir Putin continues to bomb civilian targets while Trump, not only turns a blind eye, but offers him support via this diesel deal. The EU needs to increase sanctions on Russia and the Irish Government needs to show its support by backing any effort to ban the sale of alumina from Aughinish to Russian smelters. – Yours, etc, DES MOONEY, Gorey, Co Wexford. RTÉ funding commitments Sir, – Barry Walsh (Letters, October 10th) should not have been surprised that Coimisiún na Meán issued a statement about the decision of the Minister for Media to renege on the Government’s three-year funding commitment to RTÉ . As the statement reminds us, article five of The European Media Freedom Act 2024 (EMFA) requires EU member states to put in place funding procedures that guarantee public service media adequate, sustainable and predictable financial resources while safeguarding their editorial independence. The EMFA, which became law in Ireland in August 2025, requires EU member states to put in place an independent authority, free from political influence by governments, to monitor the application of this requirement and that the results of such monitoring should be made public. Coimisiún na Meán was merely fulfilling its obligations under the EMFA by issuing the statement. Predictable (and therefore multiannual) funding is essential to the editorial independence of RTÉ and TG4. The Broadcasting Amendment Bill being guided by the Minister for Media through the Oireachtas requires Coimisiún Na Meán to undertake three-year appraisals of RTÉ and TG4, starting in 2027, and to recommend levels of funding for RTÉ and TG4 for those three years. However, the Bill does not require the Government to offer three-year funding to either RTÉ or TG4. The events of last week in relation to RTE’s funding could be repeated without apparently breaching the provisions of the Bill. Whether the Bill complies with the EMFA (which the Bill says it is implementing) will be a matter for Coimisiún na Meán to monitor and report on. I think we will be hearing from Coimisiún Na Meán again on this. – Yours, etc, JAMES HICKEY. Dublin. Prisoner rehabilitation Sir, – Breda O’Brien’s article on our penal system was most disturbing and sad and a shocking reflection of the lack of compassion in our society (“ Ireland may not have the death penalty, but we have no reason for complacency ”, Opinion, October 11th). We have read so many reports on the overcrowding and the absence of attempts at rehabilitation, but her article detailing the treatment, or mostly lack thereof, starkly emphasises a cruel indifference to our fellow men and women. How can we continue to tolerate such disregard of basic human rights? As someone who writes to prisoners on death row in the US, I deplore the death penalty and find the case of Christa Pike horrific, but, as O’Brien points out, “even in the absence of the death penalty here, we are still far from a penal system that respects the rights of everyone”. It is well past time we sought to rectify this and to rehabilitate prisoners. – Yours, etc, MARY STEWART, Donegal. James Joyce and AI Sir, – James Joyce wrote in a university submission in Padua in 1912, when asked to write about the progress made by mankind since the Renaissance: “The much-trumpeted progress of this century consists largely of a heap of machines the very purpose of which is to gather in haste and fury the scattered elements of utility and knowledge and to redistribute them to each member of the collectivity who is in a position to pay a slight tax.” He could well be talking today about the utility of AI. – Yours, etc, CIARAN CONNELL, Ranelagh, Dublin 6. Trump-induced insomnia Sir, – Will anyone join me in a class action to sue US president Donald Trump for all the worry, stress, anxiety and insomnia that his erratic words create around the world? – Yours, etc, MARTYN TODD, Lisburn.