Invesco's Top 10 Banks ETF vs Banking Mutual Funds: Which Is Better for Investors?
Investors looking to gain exposure to India's banking sector now have another passive investment option. Invesco Mutual Fund's Top 10 Banks ETF tracks an index of ten leading Indian banks, allowing investors to participate in their performance through a single exchange-traded fund. But how does this approach compare with investing in actively managed banking and financial services mutual funds? With both options offering exposure to the sector, the key question is whether investing in the country's largest banks through an ETF can be a better alternative to relying on active fund management.
What Is Invesco's Top 10 Banks ETF?
Invesco India BSE Top 10 Banks ETF is a passively managed exchange-traded fund designed to track the BSE Top 10 Banks Index. The index comprises ten leading banking stocks selected based on their free-float market capitalisation. Rather than relying on a fund manager to select stocks, the ETF follows the index's composition and weight allocation.
Investors can buy and sell units of the ETF on stock exchanges, just like listed shares. This allows them to gain exposure to a basket of India's leading banks through a single investment, without having to purchase each stock individually.
How Do Banking and Financial Services Mutual Funds Invest?
Unlike ETFs that track a predetermined index, actively managed banking and financial services mutual funds rely on fund managers to select stocks and decide their portfolio allocations. These funds primarily invest in companies operating in the banking and financial services sector, including private and public sector banks.
Depending on their investment mandates, they can also allocate money to non-banking financial companies (NBFCs), insurance companies and other financial businesses. This gives fund managers greater flexibility to adjust portfolios based on their assessment of individual companies and market opportunities, rather than following fixed index weights.
ETF vs Banking Mutual Funds: How Do Their Portfolios Compare?
One of the key differences between Invesco's Top 10 Banks ETF and actively managed banking and financial services mutual funds lies in how they construct their portfolios. While the ETF follows a predetermined index of ten banks, actively managed funds have greater flexibility in selecting companies and deciding how much to invest in each.
Which banks make up Invesco's Top 10 Banks ETF?
The ETF tracks the BSE Top 10 Banks Index, which provides exposure to ten banking stocks. Its portfolio follows the index's constituent selection and weighting methodology, with allocations determined by the banks' respective index weights.
Bank
Index weight
HDFC Bank
30.97%
ICICI Bank
23.45%
Kotak Mahindra Bank
10.46%
Axis Bank
9.53%
State Bank of India
9.24%
Federal Bank
4.96%
IndusInd Bank
3.20%
AU Small Finance Bank
2.83%
IDFC First Bank
2.79%
Bank of Baroda
2.56%
Total
99.99%
Source: Invesco India BSE Top 10 Banks ETF Scheme Information Document. Index weights as of October 27, 2026. Total may differ from 100% due to rounding.
The allocation shows that the ETF is considerably concentrated in a handful of large lenders. HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank alone account for approximately 54.42% of the underlying index, while the top three holdings, including Kotak Mahindra Bank, make up nearly 64.88%.
Do banking mutual funds invest in the same banks?
A look at September 2026 portfolio disclosures shows that actively managed banking and financial services mutual funds also allocate substantial portions of their portfolios to several of the ETF's largest constituents.
Bank
SBI Banking & Financial Services Fund
ICICI Prudential Banking & Financial Services Fund
Kotak Banking & Financial Services Fund
HDFC Bank
13.04%
13.84%
11.28%
ICICI Bank
12.77%
13.46%
12.67%
Kotak Mahindra Bank
10.19%
9.36%
3.69%
Axis Bank
2.82%
8.88%
7.36%
State Bank of India
0.00%
5.23%
8.31%
Source: September 2026 scheme portfolio disclosures. Portfolio weights as a percentage of scheme NAV.
The comparison highlights considerable overlap between the ETF's constituents and actively managed mutual fund portfolios. HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank and Kotak Mahindra Bank feature prominently across all three schemes. However, their allocations vary depending on each fund manager's investment strategy.
For instance, HDFC Bank accounts for 30.97% of the ETF's underlying index, compared with allocations ranging from 11.28% to 13.84% across the three mutual funds. Similarly, while State Bank of India makes up 9.24% of the ETF, SBI Banking & Financial Services Fund had no allocation to the bank in its September portfolio.
This illustrates an important difference between the two approaches. The ETF follows predetermined index weights, whereas active fund managers can increase, reduce or even exit their exposure to individual banks based on their assessment of the companies and market conditions.
How do the two investment approaches differ?
Beyond their common holdings, the ETF and actively managed banking mutual funds differ in the range of companies they can invest in and how their portfolios are managed.
Parameter
Invesco Top 10 Banks ETF
Banking and financial services mutual funds
Investment approach
Passive
Active
Stock selection
Follows the underlying index
Decided by fund managers
Banking exposure
Ten index constituents
Can invest across a wider range of banks
Exposure beyond banks
Limited to the index's banking constituents
Can include NBFCs, insurers and other financial companies
Portfolio allocation
Follows index weights
Adjusted according to fund managers' decisions
Portfolio concentration
Focused on ten banks
Varies across schemes
The ETF offers a rules-based way to invest in ten leading banks, whereas actively managed funds can build portfolios around a wider range of financial businesses.
Also read : 10 Mutual Funds that Hold Up to 24.63% in Adani Group Shares - Check Their 3-Year Returns
Performance, Costs and Risk: Which Approach Has the Edge?
One limitation of investing in a newly launched ETF is the absence of a historical performance record. Since Invesco's Top 10 Banks ETF is designed to track the BSE Top 10 Banks Index, investors can examine the index's historical performance to understand how its underlying basket of banks has performed. However, this should not be treated as the ETF's actual investment returns.
Actively managed banking mutual funds, meanwhile, have existing performance records that investors can evaluate across different market cycles. Their returns depend on the fund manager's stock selection, portfolio allocation and investment decisions.
Costs are another important consideration. ETFs generally have lower operating expenses than actively managed funds, although investors must also account for brokerage charges, bid-ask spreads and other trading costs. The ETF's expense ratio and tracking error will therefore be important factors to examine.
Risk also differs between the two approaches. The ETF's exposure is concentrated in ten banks, with its three largest constituents accounting for nearly 65% of the index. Actively managed funds may offer exposure to a wider range of financial companies, although their concentration levels vary across schemes. Ultimately, lower costs and passive exposure may appeal to some investors, while others may prefer the flexibility of active management.
Which Approach Should Investors Choose?
Choosing between Invesco’s Top 10 Banks ETF and an actively managed banking mutual fund comes down to how much concentration and flexibility you want in your portfolio.
Choose the Top 10 Banks ETF if you want a low-cost, rules-based way to track India’s largest lenders. It works best for investors comfortable with heavy concentration—where nearly 65% of the portfolio sits in just three banks—and who do not want to rely on a fund manager's stock picks.
Choose an actively managed banking mutual fund if you want broader financial sector exposure beyond traditional banks, including NBFCs and insurers. It suits investors who prefer a fund manager to actively adjust allocations across market cycles and are willing to pay higher fees for that flexibility
Before investing, weigh the ETF’s expense ratio and tracking error against the historical track record and portfolio strategy of active funds to see which aligns best with your goals.