The Irish Times view on mortgage arrears: a longstanding legacy of the crash
A recent study by the Central Bank has shone a light on one of the less obvious legacies of the financial crash. Almost 20 years since the global economic crisis exposed the fatal flaws in the Irish banking system, a small but persistent cohort of Celtic Tiger mortgage borrowers remain caught in a debt trap. The bank examined more than 20,000 people who are over 90 days behind on their mortgage repayments and concluded that about one third of them have little or no chance of clearing their loans by the time they retire. Most are 50 years or older, which suggests that their problems date back to the crash. They have been availing of the forbearance lenders are required to offer by law, but as they approach retirement age there will be a need for more permanent solutions. Two thirds of these borrowers already find themselves in the hands of Loan Serving Firms (LSF) who either bought their mortgages from the retail banks rescued by the taxpayer, or act on behalf of investment funds who did so. LSFs are subject to the same arrears rules as banks when it comes to dealing with struggling borrowers, but they typically charge higher mortgage rates. Because of this, political assurances that borrowers would not be worse of because their loans were sold ring a bit hollow. The problem will likely manifest first in LSFs as the distressed borrowers on their books tend to be older – 50 per cent are over 56 – and, according to the Central Bank, some 45 per cent of them will not be able to clear their mortgage before retirement. The comparable figure for those with loans with the main banks is 18 per cent. The issue will crystallise in the coming years as these individual’s approach retirement. The Government would be well advised to move to ensure that adequate alternative arrangements building on the existing Mortgage to Rent scheme and the system of Personal Insolvency Arrangements are in place and are made available. Many funds have already made a decent return on their investment. It is time to give borrowers who really cannot pay a break.