‘Don’t look at the action, look at the result of the action’: Driven by disruption, guided by culture
For Institute of Directors (IoD) Ireland member Michael Walsh, staying open to new ideas is as important in the boardroom as it has been throughout his career in financial services. From traditional banking and investment management to digital assets, his experience has reinforced the importance of culture, clear purpose and learning from directors beyond his own sector. It would be quite difficult to find someone with more financial services experience and expertise than Michael Walsh. Over the past four decades he has seen a complete transformation in the sector having started out in a treasury role with KBC Irish Intercontinental Bank. His CV includes senior roles with BNP Paribas, ABN Amro, Royal Bank of Scotland, and Lloyds Banking Group and a three-year stint as chief executive of a hedge fund. Having returned fund money to investors he was asked by Standard Chartered Bank to help establish a new digital assets business, Zodia Markets, which he led as chief executive, and later chair, in Ireland, for almost five years until May of this year. He has remained in the digital assets space as chair of Kraken Digital Asset Exchange and also serves on the boards of specialised fan engagement platform Tinvex and global online payment processor CCBill. “When I started, my first few years in financial markets involved trades written out on three-part carbon-copy forms and input by the middle office,” he recalls. “The idea of instant payments or digital assets would have sounded like science fiction.” Financial services wasn’t his first career choice. However, armed with a law degree he started his working life as an apprentice solicitor. “It is fair to say the career, and I were not a match made in heaven,” he says. “In fact, I was terrible at it.” But it did have a part to play in his change of direction. “I have always been an early riser, and I found myself first into the office each morning, picking up the newspapers from the doormat,” he explains. “This was 1986, the time of Big Bang and financial deregulation in the City of London, and I was fascinated. I found myself reading the Financial Times or Business & Finance Magazine all the time. Financial services was a very exciting place to work. I made the leap because it interested me and I wasn’t very good at being an apprentice solicitor.” His move from KBC to BNP Paribas saw him working with hedge funds on derivatives. “Every move I made was driven by the opportunity to learn and grow,” he says. “I think of financial innovation as a mosquito coil: you want to be where the edge is glowing hot, not falling away with the grey ash where financial solutions have become highly commoditised.” The move from traditional financial services into more entrepreneurial and digital asset-based businesses required new learnings, or more to the point, unlearnings. One of the most important things Walsh had to unlearn was inaction. “There’s always somewhere to hide in a 100,000-person organisation,” he says. “There’s nowhere to hide in a lean disruptive business. Every small action you take - or, more crucially, neglect to take - moves the needle. It has a profound impact on culture, working capital and broader success.” The decision to move from hands-on executive roles into the non-executive world was motivated in part by desire to bring his long experience to bear. “I had more to add to strategy and governance than to execution and tactics,” he explains. “There came a point where I had been through so many iterations of economic cycles that I recognised there was value in the things I was doing instinctively - a bit like a fish realising it has learned the art of breathing in water.” The difference between leading from the chief executive’s office and helping to guide and govern from the boardroom is very important. “You get a chance to sit back and reflect and look at culture, in particular,” he notes. “When you’re an executive, you’re busy executing strategy. It probably took me until I was a chair to realise how important culture is to how the whole organisation operates and how it makes everybody feel in the organisation. Culture isn’t just a warm, cuddly concept, it has an effect on your bottom line. “If you have the right culture, everybody understands what’s going on, and everyone’s in the same boat rowing in the same direction. That was the most important thing I learned after I made the switch.” That opportunity to step back and reflect also connects with what Walsh values in his IoD Ireland membership: exchanging perspectives with directors beyond financial services, where different businesses face many of the same governance questions. Making the step back from the hands-on role can be difficult though. The adjustment didn’t come easily, he confesses. “But you learn very quickly that there are commercial decisions that are not yours to make. You learn that very, very quickly. After that, you’d be surprised, particularly in a very fast-growing or innovative business, just how much time you spend with the senior leadership team. “There’s no status quo when you’re designing the future, there’s this constant discussion about what the right direction might be,” he continues. “It’s probably more hands-on than working in a traditional, well-established business.” It is nice to be able to sit back and play to what you know, rather than what you do, he adds. “That’s a really good feeling. I’m the one that asks, is this action or is that action appropriate for what we’re doing? Is it the right direction? An analogy which I’ve been using for 30 years is if you’re out sailing a boat and you want to change the shape of the sail, you do it by pulling on one of the ropes, but what you need to look at is not the rope, you look at the shape of the sail. That is something you have to keep bringing people back to. Don’t look at the action, look at the result of the action. Sometimes you get evangelists in the technology sector, and you’ve got to ask, what is this for?” This raises the question of what boards might need to do differently in the digital assets sector, which has seen its fair share of failures and scandals. “There’s more public scrutiny on a financial disruptor and that isn’t specific to the digital assets business,” he notes. “They probably make better headlines. There is a bit more scrutiny, both from the public interest point of view and also from a regulatory point of view. I think the Central Bank of Ireland does a great job. They’re seen as a gilt-edge regulator. You really do need credible boards.” He does not believe the speed at which such businesses operate makes for hasty board decisions. “By the time they get to the board, the proposals are extremely well laid out. You’re talking about highly professional people who have come from backgrounds in a mixture of traditional finance and technology who lay out a proposition very well and who are used to doing it. These are people who could run any sort of business. They’re not cowboys. The board gets sight of proposals well in advance. It’s not like you’re making a snap decision on the board. It’s a snap decision by the measure of a traditional financial institution, but it’s well considered in terms of financial disruption.” As an IoD Ireland member he believes strongly in the value of staying connected with directors operating beyond his immediate sector. “IoD Ireland is the only non-industry-specific forum where a director can cross-pollinate ideas with directors from other sectors,” he says. “It is exceptionally instructive to share perspectives with people leading such different entities as a semi-State body, a bank, a manufacturing plc and a financial disruptor. We run on the same governance rails, but each of us can learn from the different drivers of the others. “It goes well beyond commerce,” he adds. “As George Bernard Shaw is often credited with saying: ‘If you have an apple and I have an apple and we exchange them, we each still have one apple; but if you have an idea and I have an idea and we exchange them, we each have two ideas’. That is where IoD diversity is worth its weight in gold, or perhaps Bitcoin.” Learn more about how IoD Ireland provides members like Michael with access to director education, resources and supports, events and a powerful network of business leaders across Ireland.