In The Rings of Power, what if Sauron is just an ambitious dose, like a Young Fine Gaeler?
If I could invite three dead literary greats to dinner it would be Agatha Christie , Jane Austen and JRR Tolkien – and I would, of course, ask them the big questions: “How can I develop a piece of exploitable IP with cross-platform franchise potential?” and “Can you introduce me to Ted Sarandos from Netflix ?” and “Would you write on The Avengers if you got the call from Disney?” and “Can I have some money?” The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (Prime) is, in many ways, doing everything right when it comes to exploiting Tolkien’s IP. It has Hunky Sauron (Charlie Vickers), who has a whole body to go with his googly eye. (As it’s Christmas , I advise you to sing the words “Hunky Sauron” to the tune of Little Donkey whenever he’s on-screen.) There’s Baby Gandalf (Daniel Weyman), a youthful analogue of the fan favourite, similar to Baby Yoda in The Mandalorian, except hairier and sadly lacking Baby Yoda’s muppety, voice-of-a-generation charisma. And there’s the warrior Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) to offset the Boy’s Own-adventure vibe of the original. The Rings of Power is, in short, the very model of a big TV spectacle. And changes are afoot. Towards the end of the first episode of the third season the posh elves Galadriel and Arondir are confronted with something they’ve never experienced before: a cockney. His name is Marnûkh and he has green skin, eats bugs and curses prodigiously, like many of the cockneys we have seen over the years. And yet he wants to help – unlike, for example, the Scottish, who live under a mountain bickering among themselves, and the other cockneys who are roaming the land causing chaos at the behest of their boss Sauron. “Cockneys,” I cry, shaking my fist at the sky when they come grunting on-screen. I know what they’re like. Two of my nephews are cockneys. In the books, JRR Tolkien called the cockneys “orcs” and the Scottish people who lived under the mountain “dwarves”. Here in the TV show, however, the underlying sociological realities have been made plain thanks to some excellent accent work. The hobbits are, for the record, “Irish” in this iteration of Middle-earth, but they haven’t turned up in the third series as yet. For a chunk of the first four episodes, Galadriel and Arondir and their cockney orc follow the template set by chosen one Frodo, faithful retainer Sam and troublesome, gruesome guide Gollum. I am Helen review: Unflinching Nicola Coughlan performance makes for difficult viewing It works quite well as pastiche. But if The Rings of Power has a fatal flaw it’s that most of its heroes are overpowered warriors and not out-of-their-depth Everymen, as per the source material, and the action is also often far too sprawling, with huge CGI cities and warring armies and loads of royal succession. At no point does anyone say: “Hey, why don’t we govern as an autonomous workers’ collective?” Sadly, it’s easier to imagine the end of Middle-earth than to imagine the end of feudalism. (Apologies to the late political theorist Mark Fisher.) Nonetheless, having the narrative pared down occasionally allows the story to breathe a little. This subplot even ends with Galadriel hailing an eagle taxi to fetch her from danger. (Frodo and Sam travelled by eagle at the end of The Return of the King.) I also quite like the domestic squabbles between the dwarf king Durin, his wife Disa and his traitorous brother Thráin (though when Durin calls “Thráin” in anguish and anger it does remind me of my editor yelling “Freyne” in anguish and anger). In Númenor, meanwhile, factions fight over leadership. Baby Gandalf is off in the east, where he’s squaring up very, very slowly to another dark wizard who feels suspiciously like Saruman (though this one is played by the excellent Ciarán Hinds). And in Mordor, Sauron spends his time glowering at volcanoes. Oh, I forgot to say that Sauron is a whingy crybaby now. When he was a big inflamed eye perched atop a tower he had a certain unknowable, uncanny mystique about him. In retrospect that was most likely conjunctivitis. You Can See Everything: The strange story behind the buzziest, weirdest film of the year Nonetheless, in the original Lord of the Rings trilogy I felt inclined to hear Sauron out. “That big googly eye knows what’s what,” I’d say to my wife. “He has policies on forest clearance, orc welfare and the redistribution of magic jewellery. “Those elitists elves are fine, but there’s been no real economic development in Middle-earth for thousands of years. I suspect, in fact, that they just want to hang around in meadows all day, reading poems and pronouncing words in an interesting fashion.” Now I’ve experienced three series of Hunky Sauron scowling hotly, however, I’m beginning to find him a bit of a bore. Who would have thought that giving the eponymous Lord of the Rings a face and limbs would make him less charismatic and, frankly, less attractive? (Wistfully: Oh, the googly Eye of Sauron and the way it might look at you.) Was Sauron’s mysterious aura simply that he was in a big sulk all along? Yes, apparently. He spends his time getting visiting dignitaries to fight to the death over his magic rings and he throws his employees into the waiting maw of a big flying wyrm. (Mordor has a very poor HR department.) Friends of Eon: The 1970s group that paved the way for transgender equality in Ireland In general, I’m just not sure about having every corner of a fantasy world prequelised into soupy mush. Do we need to know where Gandalf got his hat? Are we that interested in the metallurgical details of how Sauron created his magic golden hoop? Did we really need to have more Tom Bombadil, excised from previous incarnations, uttering doggerel and being whimsical and vague? (At least they didn’t make him cool by giving him a leather jacket and a cigarette.) Characters are often far more fascinating the less we know about them. This is particularly true when it comes to a certified mythology-sponge like JRR Tolkien. Contemporary television writing is too influenced by post-Freudian interpersonal melodrama to be able to properly contend with Tolkien’s more mythic register. The contemporary writers’ room strives to make all characters psychologically plausible despite the fact that often “just because” works better in epics. So The Rings of Power asks questions like: What if the eerie and inhuman Galadriel actually has PTSD? What if one of the terrifying Black Riders is really a baby-faced, angry teenager with a reverb unit in his helmet? And, most annoyingly, what if Sauron isn’t an eerie avatar of darkness but just a very ambitious dose, much like a junior partner at an auditing firm or a member of Young Fine Gael? He really does feel like a man who has a CV in a laminated folder. I definitely liked him more when he was ocular evil on a stick. All this said, I still binge-watched all six episodes so far. You can take the nerd out of Kildare, but he still can’t resist a trip to Mordor if one’s going.