Why did huge swathes of the internet suddenly go offline yesterday?
It caught countless website developers off guard and has left many wondering how protected their cyber systems really are. When the team behind computer programming language PHP, which powers an estimated 70 per cent of all websites, warned on Wednesday that its software contained “critical vulnerabilities”, it sent the internet into a frenzy. “Who is at risk: all PHP installations serving web requests,” the developers put it bluntly, but not so simply – “all installations serving web requests” means, in layman’s terms, a website that you can click on. Users were advised to update immediately or take their sites offline to avoid a cyberattack. While the vulnerability was largely contained within 24 hours of being identified, the fright it has caused will not be easily forgotten. What is PHP? “It’s essentially a framework that websites run on,” says Martin Potgieter, the chief technology officer for the South African arm of Integrity 360, a Dublin-based cybersecurity consultancy firm. Revolut’s outage was a warning to us all While it’s difficult to say just how many websites run on it, estimates hover around 70 per cent. “A large number of websites on the internet are using it,” Potgieter says. “It’s an open source code, that’s why it’s so extensively used,” he adds. “Many people might say ‘oh, well, it’s an open source code so that’s why it’s insecure’, but that’s not really the case – it doesn’t make it less secure, just more available.” And what happened to it on Wednesday? “A flaw was found in the software that renders the websites using PHP vulnerable to an attack,” Potgieter says. “Once that flaw was discovered, it’s essentially a race between the PHP developers trying to create a patch quicker than news can get out and the details to exploit that vulnerability get out to the world.” ‘Critical vulnerabilities’ found in computer code supporting up to 70% of internet A “patch” is a corrective measure used to eliminate errors or issues within codes. “It’s very similar to when you get a little notification on your laptop that says Microsoft needs to do updates,” Potgieter goes on. “It’s essentially a change to the code that renders the vulnerability inoperable.” “Many people were advising to switch off your website, if you can’t patch it, because patching does take time,” he says. And thus, countless websites suddenly went offline for fear of a cyberattack. You couldn’t read an article from the Journal, you couldn’t buy a screwdriver from Woodie’s DIY and you couldn’t even access the Finnish government’s land registry records. How serious is this? “It is quite serious,” Potgieter says. “If a hacker successfully exploits the vulnerability, they can take control of that system and do what they want with it. That’s obviously high risk – they could take information off of the system or use it for another attack,” he adds. “There were reports of attempts to exploit the vulnerabilities ... I’m not sure if there’s any verified reports that they were successful – but it’s only a matter of time,” he says. If successful, hackers could control website operations or harvest users’ data, among other actions. More than half of Irish business leaders worried over ‘sophisticated cyber attacks’ by AI Brian Honan, a cybersecurity expert and chief executive of BH Consulting, says “it’s not rare for a big vulnerability to be found in a piece of software, but I think the impact of this vulnerability will be a surprise due to the fact that the software is used so widely”. “The vulnerabilities are of a very high severity and would actually enable a potential attacker to remotely control and manage a website to do what they want with it,” he adds. “The impact of this is huge,” Honan says, “there are websites that are liable to be taken over.” And who caught the issue? Honan says “there’s continuous research by security professionals worldwide into looking for weaknesses in software so that they can go back to vendors and recommend to them how to improve the software and make the platforms more secure”. “With the advent of AI [ artificial intelligence ] platforms and tools, that makes the research much more scalable and, in some ways, easier to carry out. Researchers can find more vulnerabilities than they could beforehand thanks to AI.” OpenAI , the force behind ChatGPT, was quick to take credit. “We led a coalition of maintainers, researchers and security providers to address critical vulnerabilities in PHP,” the company said in a statement on Tuesday. “Given the severity of these flaws and PHP’s widespread use, we consider this one of the most impactful security issues in recent memory,” OpenAI said. But Potgieter is less convinced. “Sometimes, these AI labs take credit for AI being used as part of this research, but in many cases, it wouldn’t be possible without humans either starting the process or guiding the AI through it.”