Minister defends €102m investment in horse and greyhound racing
Minister for Agriculture Martin Heydon has defended the State’s €102 million investment in the horse and greyhound racing industries as part of the Government’s “ongoing commitment to supporting rural communities”. He introduced a motion seeking Dáil approval for the continued funding of the sector amid trenchant Opposition criticism and claims the €20 million funding for greyhounds represented “cash for cruelty”. The allocation for 2027 is split into 80 per cent or €81.6 million for Horse Racing Ireland (HRI) and 20 per cent or €20.4 million for Rásaíocht Con Éireann (RCÉ), the former Irish Greyhound Board. TDs divided broadly on urban rural lines in support or opposition to funding for the greyhound industry in the wake of a Parliamentary Budgetary Office (PBO) report. It questioned the State’s continued funding of Greyhound Racing Ireland after it emerged the €20 million State subsidy made up half its income in 2024. It also pointed to the high dog mortality rate between three and five years of age. Greyhounds have a life expectancy of between 10 and 14 years. Heydon said the €600,000 increase in funding this year is linked to both equine and greyhound welfare and integrity. Sinn Féin agriculture spokesman Martin Kenny said his party supported the motion recognising, the importance of the contribution of the horse and greyhound industry to the economy “across the country”. They had concerns, however, about how the money was spent and they needed to achieve the “highest standards in animal welfare” because there were many “who treat their animals very poorly”. His party colleague Shónagh Ní Raghallaigh said “at minimum” the Minister should be questioning RCÉ about their value for money and standards in animal welfare. Social Democrats Wicklow TD Jennifer Whitmore said the greyhound industry had “systemic animal welfare issues”. Some 8,414 greyhounds of 12,766 born between 2021 and 2024 were dead, “an incredibly high mortality rate”. Her party colleague Gary Gannon said it was “laughable” there is no mention of greyhounds in the new animal welfare strategy launched earlier this month but €20.4 million will go to a “despicable” sector “involved in the “mass murdering” of dogs. Green Party leader Roderic O’Gorman said the “horrendous cost of this State-sponsored life support is measured in the deaths of dogs”. He added: “Today we’re being asked to approve cash for cruelty.” Fianna Fáil Carlow-Kilkenny TD Peter “Chap” Cleere, however, staunchly defended the sectors. “I’ve seen first-hand the benefit that both greyhound and horse racing have given to rural Ireland.” More than 30,000 people work in the horse racing sector and over 4,500 in the greyhound sector, “and they contribute billions of euro to the Irish economy”. People in these sectors were worried, he said, that with the Opposition wanting to ban the greyhound sector they would go after the horse industry next. “And this is coming from parties, who haven’t got a bull’s notion about rural Ireland. Not a continental do you know about it. And you’ve probably never gone to a track in your life.” Labour’s Robert O’Donoghue said a significant proportion of the fund goes toward prize money and they had to understand “whether this is the most effective use of public resources”. He introduced an amendment calling for a “genuinely independent assessment of the fund and its future”, the social and economic value of the industries and the conditions for employees. Independent TD Paul Gogarty who described the greyhound sector as “cruel and unviable”, said he could not support the Labour amendment because after decades of reviews, reports and controversy calling for another review is “taking the easy way out rather than doing the right thing”. The Dáil approved the funding of the horse and greyhound sector by 136 to 24 votes.