LIC Amritbaal vs Jeevan Tarun vs Children's Money Back: Which Child Insurance Plan Offers Better Returns and Protection?
Planning a child's future requires more than building savings; it also means ensuring financial goals remain protected if the earning parent passes away. LIC's Amritbaal, Jeevan Tarun and New Children's Money Back Plan offer different payout structures, but how do they compare when the Premium Waiver Benefit Rider is included? Let's examine which plan offers the better combination of returns, flexibility and financial protection.
Three LIC Child Plans: How Do Their Payout Structures Differ?
LIC's Amritbaal, Jeevan Tarun and New Children's Money Back Plan cater to parents looking to build a financial corpus for their children, but their payout structures differ considerably. Amritbaal focuses on guaranteed additions, while Jeevan Tarun offers flexibility through four survival benefit options. The New Children's Money Back Plan, on the other hand, offers regular withdrawals at regular periods, suitable for parents who want funds at different stages of their child's life.
LIC Amritbaal is a non-participating and non-linked individual savings life insurance plan. It provides for guaranteed additions of ₹80 per ₹1,000 of Basic Sum Assured per policy year. Parents may also select maturity between 18 and 25 years, allowing them to align the payout with their child's expected education or other expenses.
LIC Jeevan Tarun is a participating plan, which provides four survival benefit options. Parents can choose to receive 0%, 5%, 10% or 15% of the Basic Sum Assured every year from the age of 20 till the child turns 24. The remaining amount is paid at maturity at age 25, along with applicable bonuses. This enables parents to have more flexibility on when the money is paid.
LIC New Children's Money Back Plan follows a periodic payout structure. It pays 20% on the Basic Sum Assured at ages 18, 20 and 22 with the remaining 40% payable at maturity (age 25) with applicable bonuses. This enables parents to access money at various points in the policy, not just when it reaches maturity.
₹10 Lakh Basic Sum assured Comparison: What Does Each Plan Actually Offer?
To compare the three plans, consider parents purchasing a policy for their five-year-old daughter with a Basic Sum Assured of ₹10 lakh and a maturity age of 25 years. The premium payment period will differ across policies: a single lump-sum payment or 5, 6, or 7 years under Amritbaal, 15 years under Jeevan Tarun, and 20 years under the Children's Money Back Plan. The calculations below compare the basic survival benefits, guaranteed additions, and guaranteed maturity payouts across the three plans for a ₹10 lakh Basic Sum Assured.
1. LIC Amritbaal: Premium Paid vs Maturity Benefit
Based on LIC's illustrative rates for a five-year-old child with a ₹10 lakh Basic Sum Assured and a seven-year premium payment term, the annual premium comes to roughly ₹1,47,250 (scaled from LIC's ₹73,625 quote for a ₹5 lakh Sum Assured). The policy offers guaranteed additions of ₹80 per ₹1,000 of Basic Sum Assured for every completed policy year. This translates into ₹80,000 annually for a ₹10 lakh Sum Assured.
Particulars
Amount
Basic Sum Assured
₹10,00,000
Annual guaranteed additions
₹80,000
Policy term
20 years
Total guaranteed additions
₹16,00,000
Maturity benefit at age 25
₹26,00,000
Thus, the child receives ₹26 lakh at maturity, comprising the Basic Sum Assured and accumulated guaranteed additions, provided the policy remains in force.
2. LIC Jeevan Tarun: Premium Paid vs Maturity Benefit
Under LIC Jeevan Tarun, the premium payment term is 15 years, meaning premiums are payable until the child turns 20. The policy then continues, providing survival benefits between ages 20 and 24, followed by the maturity payout at age 25.
For this calculation, Option 3 is selected, which provides an annual survival benefit of 10% of the Basic Sum Assured for five years, followed by ₹5 lakh at age 25, plus applicable bonuses.
Particulars
Amount
Basic Sum Assured
₹10,00,000
Annual survival benefit (10%)
₹1,00,000
Payout period
5 years
Total survival benefits
₹5,00,000
Maturity benefit (50%)
₹5,00,000
Total basic benefits
₹10,00,000
Thus, Jeevan Tarun allows parents to fund the policy for 15 years while providing the child with financial support during five consecutive years, plus vested Simple Reversionary Bonuses and Final Additional Bonus (FAB) at maturity.
Also read: JioBlackRock Flexi Cap Fund Exits ITC, TCS and 19 Other Stocks, Adds 13 New Ones: Check October Portfolio Changes
3. LIC New Children's Money Back Plan: Premium Paid vs Maturity Benefit
Under this plan, base premiums are payable throughout the 20-year policy term until the child turns 25 (though the optional Premium Waiver Benefit Rider covers premiums only up to the rider term). Unlike Jeevan Tarun, which allows parents to choose from four payout options, this plan follows a fixed money-back structure.
The child receives 20% of the Basic Sum Assured at ages 18, 20 and 22, followed by the remaining 40% at maturity at age 25.
Particulars
Amount
Basic Sum Assured
₹10,00,000
Payout at age 18 (20%)
₹2,00,000
Payout at age 20 (20%)
₹2,00,000
Payout at age 22 (20%)
₹2,00,000
Payout at age 25 (40%)
₹4,00,000
Total basic benefits
₹10,00,000
Thus, the plan provides access to a portion of the insured amount at three important milestones, while retaining the remaining amount for maturity.
Premium Waiver Benefit Rider: What Happens If the Parent Dies?
Premium Waiver Benefit Rider protects your child's policy against death of the parent or proposer during the life of the rider. If the claim is accepted, then the ongoing premiums, according to the base policy, are eliminated, and the policy proceeds to its regular benefits.
For instance, if a parent purchases a policy when their child is five and passes away when the child turns 10, after paying five years of premiums, the remaining premiums are waived, subject to rider conditions. Amritbaal continues accumulating guaranteed additions, Jeevan Tarun retains its selected survival benefits, and the Children's Money Back Plan continues with its scheduled payouts. This is an optional rider, which comes with a higher premium, but no extra lump sum payout. Availability is subject to Policy and Premium Payment Option.
Conclusion
LIC Amritbaal, Jeevan Tarun and New Children's Money Back Plan cater to different financial goals. While Amritbaal offers higher guaranteed additions (though potentially subject to tax if annual premiums exceed 10% of the Sum Assured), Jeevan Tarun and the Children's Money Back Plan offer tax-free maturity benefits along with non-guaranteed bonuses and milestone payouts. However, choosing between them requires looking beyond maturity benefits. The Premium Waiver Benefit Rider provides an additional benefit by waiving further premiums upon the death of the proposer (as long as the policy conditions are met). The payout mechanisms, premiums promised and the eligibility for riders should be compared to ensure the chosen plan best aligns with the parents' budget and the child's future financial needs.